www.vovr.ru; www.vovr.elpub.ru
Журнал издаётся с 1992 года
1
2019
НАУЧНО-ПЕДАГОГИЧЕСКИЙ ЖУРНАЛ
Содержание
Contents . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .3
Направления модернизации образования
И.В. БРЕЙДО, С.М. СТАЖКОВ, А.В. БОБРЯКОВ, В.Г. ХОМЧЕНКО,
А.А. КАБАНОВ, Б. КАТАЛИЧ. Международный сетевой интернет-проект
интегрированного инженерного образования . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .9
Yu. B. RUBIN, M.V. LEDNEV, D.P. MOZHZHUKHIN.
Competition Studies: Structuring Competencies in University
Entrepreneurship Programs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .21
Социология образования
Г.М. РОМАНОВА, В.П. ЕРДАКОВА, М.А. МАЗНИЧЕНКО.
Реализация академических прав студентов: Россия в Болонском
процессе . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .34
М.А. ЛУКАШЕНКО, А.А. ОЖГИХИНА. Имидж преподавателя вуза:
мнения и приоритеты студентов . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .46
В.В. РЕТИВИНА. Трудовые ценности и установки студенческой
молодежи . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .57
Стр.3
ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ
О
Соучредители: Московский
политехнический
университет;
Ассоциация технических
университетов
Партнеры:
НИЯУ МИФИ,
ННГУ им. Н.И.Лобачевского,
КНИТУ,
РГГУ,
ТвГУ,
РосНОУ
Главный редактор:
М. Б. Сапунов
Зам. главного редактора:
Е. А. Гогоненкова
Н. П. Лябина
Редакторы:
О. Ю. Миронова
Ответственный секретарь:
Л. Ю. Одинокова
Корректор:
М. В. Куликова
Технический редактор:
Д. В. Давыдова
Художник:
Н. Н. Жильцов
Адрес редакции:
127550, Москва,
ул. Прянишникова, д. 2А
Юридический адрес:
107023, Москва,
ул. Б. Семёновская, д. 38
Тел./факс: (499) 976-07-46
e-mail: vovrus@inbox.ru
vovr@bk.ru
Журнал зарегистрирован
в Роскомнадзоре
Рег. св. ПИ № ФС7754511
от 17 июня 2013 года
Подписано в печать с
оригинал-макета 27.12.2018
Усл. п. л. 11. Тираж 600 экз.
Отпечатано в типографии
ППП «Типография
“Наука”». Зак. №
© «Высшее образование
в России»
www.vovr.ru;
www.vovr.elpub.ru
Круглый стол
Новая модель российской аспирантуры: проблемы
и перспективы ...................................... 130
Педагогика высшей школы
К.М. ИНОЗЕМЦЕВА, Н.О. ТРУФАНОВА,
А.К. КРУПЧЕНКО. Модель повышения
квалификации преподавателя иностранного языка
технического вуза .................................. 147
Указатель статей за 2018 год
158
«Синергия – 2018»
С.В. ЮШКО, М.Ф. ГАЛИХАНОВ, В.В. КОНДРАТЬЕВ.
Интегрированная подготовка будущих инженеров
к инновационной деятельности для постиндустриальной
экономики .......................................... 65
R. DREHER, A.O. GORNOV, V.V. KONDRATYEV.
Concept of the Natural Structure of Engineering Training
and the Code of Professional Ethics of an Engineer ...... 76
М.Т. РЕСТИВО, Ю.Н. ЗИЯТДИНОВА. Инженерное
образование как инструмент повышения
производительности труда: опыт Португалии .......... 86
С.В. БАРАБАНОВА, А.А. КАЙБИЯЙНЕН,
Н.В. КРАЙСМАН. Цифровизация образования
в глобальном контексте (обзор международных
конференций) ....................................... 94
Философия образования и науки
Д.Г. РЫНДИН. Мераб Мамардашвили: событие мысли
и педагогическая практика .......................... 104
А.А. ПОЛОННИКОВ. Образовательные политики
письма и чтения (Комментарий к статье Д.Г. Рындина) ... 119
Е
В
Е
Ы
Ш
С
С
В
Р
С
И
Стр.4
H
Higher Education in Russia • No. 1, 2019
Contents
Areas of Education Modernization
I.V. BREIDO, S.M. STAZHKOV, A.V. BOBRYAKOV,
V.G. KHOMCHENKO, A.A. KABANOV, B. KATALINIC.
International University Network Internet Project of Integrated
Engineering Education. Pp. 9-20
Yu. B. RUBIN, M.V. LEDNEV, D.P. MOZHZHUKHIN.
Competition Studies: Structuring Competencies in University
Entrepreneurship Programs. Pp. 21-33
Sociology of Education
G.M. ROMANOVA, V.P. ERDAKOVA, M.A. MAZNICHENKO.
Realization of Students’ Academic Rights: Russia in the Bologna
Process. Pp. 34-45
M.A. LUKASHENKO, A.A. OZHGIKHINA. University Professor
Image: Students’ Views and Priorities. Pp. 46-56
V.V. RETIVINA. Labor Values and Attitudes of Modern Students.
Pp. 57-63
«Synergy – 2018»
S.V. YUSHKO, M.F. GALIKHANOV, V.V. KONDRATYEV.
Integrative Training of Future Engineers for Innovative Activities
in Conditions of Post-Industrial Economy. Pp. 65-75
R. DREHER, A.O. GORNOV, V.V. KONDRATYEV.
Concept of the Natural Structure of Engineering Training
and the Code of Professional Ethics of an Engineer. Pp. 76-85
M.T. RESTIVO, J.N. ZIYATDINOVA. Engineering Education
and Labor Efficiency Skills: Experience of Portugal. Pp. 86-83
S.V. BARABANOVA, A.A. KAYBIYAYNEN, N.V. KRAYSMAN.
Digitalization of Education in the Global Context. Pp. 94-103
Philosophy of Science and Education
D.G. RYNDIN. Merab Mamardashvili: Event of Thought
and Pedagogic Practice. Pp. 104-118
A.A. POLONNIKOV. Educational Policies of Writing and
Reading (A commentary on D.G. Ryndin’s article). Pp. 119-129
Round Table Discussion
A New Model of Russian Doctoral Education: Problems
and Prospects (round table). Pp. 130-146
Higher School Pedagogy
K.M. INOZEMTSEVA, N.O. TROUFANOVA, A.K. KRUPCHENKO.
Professional Development Model for ESP Teachers Working
at Engineering Universities. Pp. 147-158
Paper Index 2018 Pp. 158-167
Moscow Polytechnic University,
Association of Technical
Universities. Founded in 1991
Сo-founders:
Editor-in-Chief:
M.B. Sapunov
Deputy Editors-in-Chief:
E.A. Gogonenkova,
N.P. Lyabina
Executive secretary:
L.Yu. Odinokova
O.Yu. Mironova
Editor:
Technical editor:
D.V. Davydova
Proof-reader:
M.V. Kulikova
Computer design:
N.N. Zhiltsov
Editorial office. Postal address:
2A, Pryanishnikova str., Moscow,
127550, Russian Federation
tel. +7 (499) 976-07-46
e-mail: vovrus@inbox.ru,
vovr@bk.ru
www.vovr.elpub.ru;
www.vovr.ru
38, Bolshaya Semenovskaya,
Moscow, 107023, Russian
Federation
Legal address:
The journal’s registration by The
Federal Service for Supervision
of Communications, Information
Technology and Mass Media was
renewed on 17 June 2013.
The Certificate of Mass Media
registration: No. FC 7754511
ISSN 0869-3617 (Print);
2072-0459 (Online)
11 issues per year
Languages: Russian, English
Indexed in Ulrich’s Periodicals
Directory, Russian Science
Citation Index, Journals Library
Cyberleninka, Google Scholar.
Printed in Publishing House
“Nauka”: 1a, Dinamovskaya str.,
Moscow, 109044
Copies printed – 700.
© Vysshee obrazovanie v Rossii
(Higher Education in Russia)
EDUCAT IO N
U
R
H
E
I
G
I
N
I
R
S
S
A
Стр.5
VYSSHEE OBRAZOVANIE V ROSSII
www.vovr.ru; www.vovr.elpub.ru
(Higher Education in Russia)
Vysshee obrazovanie v Rossii is a monthly scholarly refereed journal that
provides a forum for disseminating information about advances in higher education
among educational researchers, educators, administrators and policymakers
across Russia. The journal welcomes authors to submit articles and research/discussion
papers on topics relevant to modernization of education and
trends, challenges and opportunities in teaching and learning.
Vysshee obrazovanie v Rossii publishes articles, book reviews and conference
reports on issues such as institutional development and management, innovative
practices in university curricula, assessment and evaluation, as well as
theory and philosophy of higher education.
Vysshee obrazovanie v Rossii aims to stimulate interdisciplinary, problemoriented
and critical approach to research, to facilitate the discussion on specific
topics of interest to educational researchers including international audiences.
The primary objective of the journal is supporting of the research space
in the field of educational sciences taking into account two dimensions – geographical
and epistemological, consolidation of the broad educational community.
This can be provided by creating the unified language of understanding
and description of the processes that take place in the contemporary higher
education. This language should facilitate rallying of the whole community of
educators and researchers on the basis of such values as solidarity, concord,
cooperation, and co-creation.
Our audience includes academics, faculty and administrators, teachers, researchers,
practitioners, organizational developers, and policy designers.
The journal’s rubrics correspond to three research areas: philosophical sciences,
sociological sciences, educational sciences. We design our activities relying
on the professional associations in higher education sphere, such as the
Russian Union of Rectors, Association of Technical Universities, Association of
Classical Universities of Russia, International Society for Engineering Education
(IGIP).
Indexation. The papers in Vysshee obrazovanie v Rossii are indexed by Russian
Science Citation Index and Erich Plus.
Стр.6
ВЫСШЕЕ ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ В РОССИИ
www.vovr.ru; www.vovr.elpub.ru
НАУЧНО-ПЕДАГОГИЧЕСКИЙ ЖУРНАЛ
Журнал входит в перечень изданий, рекомендованных ВАК при Министерстве образования
и науки РФ для публикации результатов научных исследований.
Редакционная коллегия
БЕДНЫЙ Б.И. (проф., ННГУ им. Н.И. Лобачевского); БЕЛОЦЕРКОВСКИЙ А.В. (проф.,
Тверской государственный университет); БОЛОТИН И.С. (проф., Московский авиационный
институт – национальный исследовательский университет); ВЕРБИЦКИЙ А.А. (проф.,
академик РАО, МПГУ); ГРЕБНЕВ Л.С. (проф., НИУ «Высшая школа экономики»);
ГРИБОВ А.А. (проф., чл.-корр. РАН); ЖУРАКОВСКИЙ В.М. (проф., акад. РАО);
ЗБОРОВСКИЙ Г.Е. (проф., Уральский федеральный университет им. Б.Н. Ельцина);
ИВАНОВ В.Г. (проф., КНИТУ); ИВАХНЕНКО Е.Н. (проф., РГГУ); КИРАБАЕВ Н.С. (проф.,
РУДН); КУЗНЕЦОВА Н.И. (проф., РГГУ); ЛУКАШЕНКО М.А. (проф., МФПУ «Синергия»);
МЕЛИК-ГАЙКАЗЯН И.В. (проф., ТГПУ); НАБОЙЧЕНКО С.С. (проф., чл.-корр.
РАН); ПЕТРОВ В.Л. (проф., НИТУ «МИСиС»); САЗОНОВ Б.А. (гл. науч. сотрудник,
ФИРО); САЗОНОВА З.С. (проф., МАДИ); САПУНОВ М.Б. (журнал «Высшее образование
в России»); СЕНАШЕНКО B.C. (проф., РУДН); СИЛЛАСТЕ Г.Г. (проф., Финансовый
университет при Правительстве РФ); СТРИХАНОВ М.Н. (проф., ректор, НИЯУ МИФИ),
ФЕДОРОВ И.Б. (акад. РАН, Президент МГТУ им. Н.Э. Баумана); ЧУПРУНОВ Е.В. (проф.,
ректор, ННГУ им. Н.И. Лобачевского); ЧУЧАЛИН А.И. (проф., Кубанский государственный
технологический университет)
Международный редакционный совет
АЛЕКСАНДРОВ А.А. (проф., ректор, МГТУ им. Н.Э. Баумана, президент Ассоциации
технических университетов); АУЭР Михаэль (Генеральный секретарь IGIP, проф., Университет
прикладных наук Каринтии); БАДАРЧ Дендев (проф., директор департамента
ЮНЕСКО, Париж); де ГРААФ Эрик (гл. ред. European Journal of Engineering Education,
проф., Алборгский университет); ГРУДЗИНСКИЙ А.О. (проф., член рабочей группы по
Болонскому процессу при Минобрнауки России); ЖЕНЬ НАНЬЦИ (акад., Харбинский политехнический
университет, исполнительный директор АТУРК); ЗГУРОВСКИЙ М.З. (акад.
НАН Украины, ректор, Национальный технический университет Украины); ЗЕРНОВ В.А.
(проф., ректор, РосНОУ, председатель совета Ассоциации негосударственных вузов);
МАРУХЯН В.З. (проф., ректор, Национальный политехнический университет Армении);
НЕЧАЕВ В.Д. (проф., ректор, Севастопольский государственный университет);
ОЧИРБАТ Баатар (ректор, Монгольский государственный университет науки и технологий);
ПРИХОДЬКО В.М. (проф., чл.-корр. РАН, президент Российского мониторингового
комитета IGIP); РИБИЦКИС Леонид С. (проф., акад. Латвийской академии наук,
ректор, Рижский технический университет); САДОВНИЧИЙ В.А. (проф., акад. РАН, ректор,
МГУ им. М.В. Ломоносова, президент РСР); САНГЕР Филлип (проф., Университет
Пердью, США); ЮШКО С.В. (проф., ректор, КНИТУ)
Стр.7
VYSSHEE OBRAZOVANIE V ROSSII
www.vovr.ru; www.vovr.elpub.ru
(Higher Education in Russia)
EDITORIAL BOARD
Boris I. BEDNYI – Dr. Sci. (Physics), Prof., Director of the Institute of Doctoral Studies,
N.I. Lobachevsky State University of Nizhni Novgorod, bib@unn.ac.ru
Andrey V. BELOTSERKOVSKY – Dr. Sci. (Physics), Prof., Tver State University,
A.belotserkovsky@tversu.ru
Ivan S. BOLOTIN – Dr. Sci. (Philosophy), Prof., Head of the Department of Sociology and
Personnel Management, Moscow Aviation Institute (National Research University), siup@mail.ru
Alexander I. CHUCHALIN – Dr. Sci. (Engineering), Prof., Head of the Department of
Engineering Pedagogy, Kuban State Technological University, chai@tpu.ru
Evgeniy V. CHUPRUNOV – Dr. Sci. (Physics), Prof., Rector of N.I. Lobachevsky State
University of Nizhni Novgorod, rector@unn.ru
Igor B. FEDOROV – Dr. Sci. (Engineering), Prof., Academician of RAS, Bauman MSTU,
bauman@bmstu.ru
Leonid S. GREBNEV – Dr. Sci. (Economics), Prof., National Research University Higher
School of Economics, lsg-99@mail.ru
Lev A. GRIBOV – Dr. Sci. (Physics), Prof., Corr. Member of RAS, gribov@geokhi.ru
Evgeniy N. IVAKHNENKO – Dr. Sci. (Philosophy), Prof., Russian State University for the
Humanities, ivahnen@rambler.ru
Vasiliy G. IVANOV – Dr. Sci. (Education), Prof., Vice-Rector, Kazan National Research
Technological University, mrcpkrt@mail.ru
Nur S. KIRABAEV – Dr. Sci. (Philosophy), Prof., Peoples’ Friendship University of Russia,
n.kirabaev@rudn.ru
Natalia I. KUZNETSOVA – Dr. Sci. (Philosophy), Prof., Russian State University for the
Humanities, cap-cap@inbox.ru
Marianna A. LUKASHENKO – Dr. Sci. (Economics), Prof., Moscow University for Industry
and Finance “Synergy”, mlukashenko@mfpa.ru
Irina V. MELIK-GAYKAZYAN – Dr. Sci. (Philosophy), Prof., Tomsk State Pedagogical
University, melik-irina@yandex.ru
Stanislav S. NABOYCHENKO – Dr. Sci. (Engineering), Prof., Corr. Member of RAS,
tel. +7-343-375-47-95
Vadim L. PETROV – Dr. Sci. (Engineering), Prof., The National University of Science and
Technology MISiS, petrovv@misis.ru
Mikhail B. SAPUNOV – Cand. Sci. (Philosophy), Editor-in-chief of the journal “Vysshee
Obrazovanie v Rossii”, mbsapunov@mail.ru
Boris A. SAZONOV – Cand. Sci. (Engineering), Chief Researcher of the Federal Institute of
the Development of Education, bsazonov@list.ru
Zoya S. SAZONOVA – Dr. Sci. (Education), Prof., State Technical University – MADI,
zssazonova@yahoo.com
Vasiliy S. SENASHENKO – Dr. Sci. (Physics), Prof. of the Department of Comparative
Educational Policy, People’s Friendship University of Russia, vsenashenko@mail.ru
Galina G. SILLASTE – Dr. Sci. (Sociology), Prof., Financial University under the Government
of the Russian Federation, galinasillaste@yandex.ru
Mikhail N. STRIKHANOV – Dr. Sci. (Physics), Prof., Corr. Member of Russian Academy of
Education, Rector, National Research Nuclear University MEPhI, rector@mephi.ru
Стр.8
Andrey A. VERBITSKY – Dr. Sci. (Education), Prof., Academician of the Russian Academy
of Education, Moscow State Pedagogical University, asson1@rambler.ru
Garold E. ZBOROVSKY – Dr. Sci. (Philosophy), Prof., Ural Federal University named after
the first President of Russia B.N. Yeltsin, g.e.zborovsky@urfu.ru; garoldzborovsky@gmail.com
Vasiliy M. ZHURAKOVSKY – Dr. Sci. (Engineering), Prof., Academician of the Russian
Academy of Education, Head of the Expert and analytical center of National Training
Foundation, zhurakovsky@ntf.ru
INTERNATIONAL COUNCIL MEMBERS
Anatoly A. ALEXANDROV – Dr. Sci. (Engineering), Prof., Rector of Bauman Moscow
State Technical University, President of Technical Universities Association, bauman@bmstu.ru
Michael E. AUER – PhD, Prof., General Secretary of IGIP, Carinthia University of Applied
Sciences (Austria), gs@igip.org
Dendev BADARCH – PhD, Director of the Division of Social Transformations and
Intercultural Dialogue, UNESCO, France, d.badarch@unesco.org
Erik de GRAAF – Prof., Delft University of Technology (Netherlands), Editor-in-chief of the
“European Journal of Engineering Education”, degraaff@plan.aau.dk
Alexander O. GRUDZINSKY – Dr. Sci. (Sociology), Prof., Lobachevsky State University
of Nizhni Novgorod, member of the working group on Bologna Process at the Ministry of
Education and Science of RF, aog@unn.ru
Vostanik Z. MARUKHYAN – PhD, Prof., Rector of the National Polytechnic University of
Armenia, rector@seua.am
Vladimir D. NECHAEV – Dr. Sci. (Politics), Prof., Rector of Sevastopol State University,
VDNechaev@sevsu.ru
Baatar OCHIRBAT– PhD, Prof., Rector of Mongolian University of Science and Technology,
baatar@must.edu.mn
Vyacheslav M. PRIKHOD’KO – Dr. Sci. (Engineering), Prof., Corr. Member of RAS, State
Technical University – MADI, President of RMC IGIP, rector@madi.ru
Nanqi REN – Vice President of Harbin Institute of Technology, Association of Sino-Russian
Technical Universities (ASRTU), Permanent Secretariat of Chinese part, asrtu@hit.edu.cn
Leonids RIBICKIS – Dr. Sci. (Engineering), Prof., Rector of Riga Technical University,
Academician of the Latvian Academy of Sciences, leonids.ribickis@rtu.lv
Viktor A. SADOVNICHIY – Dr. Sci. (Physics), RAS Academician, Rector of Lomonosov
Moscow State University, President of the Russian Rectors’ Union, info@rector.msu.ru
Phillip A. SANGER – PhD, Full Professor, Executive Director of Center for Accelerating
Technology and Innovation, College of Technology, Purdue University, psanger@purdue.edu
Sergey V. YUSHKO – Dr. Sci. (Engineering), Prof., Rector of Kazan National Research
Technological University, office@kstu.ru
Vladimir A. ZERNOV – Dr. Sci. (Physics), Prof., Rector of Russian New University, Chairman
of the Council of the Association of Non-Governmental Universities, rector@rosnou.ru
Mykhailo Z. ZGUROVSKY – Dr. Sci. (Engineering), Prof., Rector of National Technical
University of Ukraine “Kyiv Polytechnic Institute”, Academician of NAN of Ukraine,
zgurovsm@hotmail.com
Стр.9
AUTHOR’S GUIDE
Publishing Ethics
The journal Vysshee obrazovanie v Rossii is committed to promoting the standards of publication
ethics in accordance with COPE (Code of Conduct and Best Practice Guidelines for Journal
Editors) and takes all possible measures against any publication malpractices. We pursue the
principles of transparency and best practices in scholarly publishing and aspire to ensure fair,
unbiased, and transparent peer review processes and editorial decisions.
Peer-review procedure
All the manuscripts submitted to Vysshee obrazovanie v Rossii are reviewed by the Editor
to assess its suitability for the journal according to the guidelines determined by the editorial
policy. On this step of the initial filtering the manuscript can be rejected if the content doesn’t
fall within the scope of the journal or it fails to meet sufficiently our basic criteria and the submission
requirements.
The papers accepted for publication are subjected to the blind peer review process which can
be accomplished either by the members of Editorial staff (Heads of Departments) or by involved
additional reviewers. The assigned reviewer is an expert within a topic area of the research
conducted.
Manuscript Submission
Manuscript is expected to report the original research. The paper content should be relevant
to the scope of the journal. Authors must certify that the manuscript is not currently being
considered for publication elsewhere and has not been published before.
Manuscripts are submitted at email address: vovrus@inbox.ru. They must be prepared according
to the manuscript requirements. Author’s document set should include the following
positions.
• Authors’ data: first name, middle initial and last name; affiliation (full name of the organization
and position); academic degree; postal address of the organization; e-mail address;
mobile telephone number.
• Manuscript file in Word format (font – 11-point Times New Roman).
• Title (no more than 5-7 words).
• Abstract (250-300 words summarizing concisely the content and conclusions of the
paper).
• Keywords (5-7).
• Reference list (approx. 15-20). Each reference should be numbered, ordered sequentially
as it appears in a text; all authors should be included in reference list; references to websites
should give authors if known, title of cited page, URL in full, and year of posting in
parentheses. Please, adhere the journal style of referencing.
Стр.10