¹ 11 ( 75 )
2020
Edition
ADVOCACY
Chairperson of the Council of Editors:
BLAZHEEV Victor Vladimirovich — Rector of Kutafi n Moscow
State Law University (MSAL), Professor of the Department of
Civil and Administrative Court Proceedings, Cand. Sci. (Law),
Associate Professor, Moscow, Russia
Vice-Chairperson of the Council of Editors:
GRACHEVA
Elena Yurievna — First Vice-Rector of Kutafi n
Moscow State Law University (MSAL), Head of the Department
of Financial Law, Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor, Moscow, Russia
Chief Editor:
SHPAKOVSKIY
Yuriy Grigorievich — Рrofessor of the
Department of Environmental and Natural Resources Law of
Kutafi n Moscow State Law University (MSAL), Dr. Sci. (Law),
Рrofessor, Moscow, Russia
Executive Secretary Editor:
SEVRYUGINA Olga Alexandrovna — Head of the Research and
Publishing Policy Department of the Research Institute of Kutafi n
Moscow State Law University (MSAL), Moscow, Russia
Сouncil of editors
AFANASIEV Sergey Fedorovich — Head of the Department of
Arbitrazh Procedure of Saratov State Academy of Law, Dr. Sci.
(Law), Professor, Saratov, Russia
BEZVERKHOV Arthur Gennadevich — Dean of the Law Faculty
of the National Research University named after Academician
Sergey P. Korolev, Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor, Samara, Russia
BIRIUKOV Pavel Nikolaevich — Head of the Department of
Theory of the State and Law, International Law and Comparative
Law of Voronezh State University, Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor,
Voronezh, Russia
BUKALEROVA Ludmila Alexandrovna — Head of the Department
of Criminal Law, Criminal Procedure and Criminology of the
Peoples' Friendship University of Russia, Dr. Sci. (Law),
Professor, Moscow, Russia
VOLKOV Gennadiy Aleksandrovich — Professor of the
Department of Environmental and Land Law of the Faculty of
Law of Lomonosov Moscow State University, Dr. Sci. (Law),
Moscow, Russia
Published from the year of 2014
Monthly journal
VOSKOBITOVA Lidia Alekseevna — Head of the Department of
Criminal Procedure Law of Kutafi n Moscow State Law University
(MSAL), Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor, Moscow, Russia
DUFLOT Alain — an expert practitioner in the fi eld of law, founder
of the law fi rm «Dufl ot & Partners», Lecturer at the Jean Moulin
Lyon 3 University, Lyon, France
EGOROVA Maria Alexandrovna — Professor of the Department
of Competition Law, Head of the Department of International
Cooperation of Kutafi n Moscow State Law University (MSAL), Dr.
Sci. (Law), Professor, Moscow, Russia
ERSHOVA Inna Vladimirovna — Head of the Department of
Business and Corporate Law of Kutafi n Moscow State Law
University (MSAL), Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor, Moscow, Russia
EFIMOVA Lyudmila Georgievna — Head of the Department of
Banking Law of Kutafi n Moscow State Law University (MSAL), Dr.
Sci. (Law), Professor, Moscow, Russia
ZHAVORONKOVA Natalya Grigorevna — Head of the Department
of Environmental and Natural Resources Law of Kutafi n Moscow
State Law University (MSAL), Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor, Moscow,
Russia
ZRAZHEVSKAYA Tatyana Dmitrievna — Professor of the
Department of Constitutional and Municipal Law of Voronezh
State University, Commissioner for Human Rights in the Voronezh
Region, Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor, Voronezh, Russia
ZUBAREV Sergey Mikhailovich — Head of the Department of
Administrative Law and Procedure of Kutafi n Moscow State Law
University (MSAL), Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor, Moscow, Russia
ISHCHENKO Evgeniy Petrovich — Head of the Department of
Criminalistics of Kutafi n Moscow State Law University (MSAL), Dr.
Sci. (Law), Professor, Moscow, Russia
ISHCHENKO Nina Sergeyevna — PhD in Law, Professor, Head
of the Department of Jurisprudence of the Gomel Branch of the
International University «MITSO», Gomel, Republic of Belarus
KISELEV Sergey Georgievich — Head of the Department of
Theory and History of the State and Law of the State University
of Management, Dr. Sci. (Philosophy), Professor, Moscow, Russia
KOMAROVA Valentina Viktorovna — Head of the Department of
Constitutional and Municipal Law of Kutafi n Moscow State Law
University (MSAL), Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor, Moscow, Russia
Recommended by the Higher Attestation Commission of the Ministry of Science and Higher Education
of the Russian Federation for publication of results of doctoral theses.
Materials included in the journal Russian Science Citation Index
© Kutafi n Moscow State Law University (MSAL), 2020
11/2020
Стр.5
LAPINA Marina Afanasyeva — Professor of the Department of
Legal Regulation of Economic Activity of the Financial University
under the Government of the Russia, Dr. Sci. (Law), Moscow,
Russia
LYUTOV Nikita Leonidovich — Head of the Department of Labor
and Social Security Law of Kutafi n Moscow State Law University
(MSAL), Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor, Moscow, Russia
MIROSHNICHENKO Vladimir Mikhailovich — Rector of the
Academy of Security and Special Programs, Dr. Sci. (Economics),
Professor, Moscow, Russia
NIKITIN Sergey Vasilyevich — Head of the Department of Civil
and Administrative Court Proceedings of the Russian State
University of Justice, Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor, Moscow, Russia
NOVOSELOVA Lyudmila
Alexandrovna — Head of the
Department of Intellectual Property Law of Kutafi n Moscow
State Law University (MSAL), Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor, Moscow,
Russia
PLYUSHCHIKOV Vadim Gennadyevich — Director of Agrarian
and Technological Institute of the Peoples' Friendship University
of Russia, Dr. Sci. (Agr. Sc.), Professor, Moscow, Russia
RASSOLOV Ilya Mikhailovich — Professor of the Department
of Information Law and Digital Technologies of Kutafi n Moscow
State Law University (MSAL), Dr. Sci. (Law), Associate Professor,
Moscow, Russia
ROSA Fabrice — Professor of the Department of Labour Law at
the University of Reims Champagne-Ardenne, France
ROMANOVA Victoria Valeryevna — Head of the Department of
Energy Law of Kutafi n Moscow State Law University (MSAL), Dr.
Sci. (Law), Moscow, Russia
ROSSINSKAYA Elena Rafailovna — Director of the Forensic
Examination Institute, Head of the Department of Forensic
Examination of Kutafi n Moscow State Law University (MSAL),
Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor, Moscow, Russia
RYLSKAYA Marina Alexandrovna — Director of the Institute of
Problems of the Effi cient State and Civil Society of the Financial
THE CERTIFICATE
OF MASS MEDIA
REGISTRATION
ISSN
PUBLICATION
FREQUENCY
FOUNDER AND
PUBLISHER
EDITORIAL OFFICE.
POSTAL ADDRESS
SUBSCRIPTION AND
DISTRIBUTION
PRINTING HOUSE
SIGNED FOR PRINTING
University under the Government of the Russia, Dr. Sci. (Law),
Associate Professor, Moscow, Russia
SINYUKOV Vladimir Nikolaevich — Vice-Rector for Science
of Kutafi n Moscow State Law University (MSAL), Professor of
the Department of Theory of the State and Law, Dr. Sci. (Law),
Professor, Moscow, Russia
SOKOLOVA Natalya Alexandrovna — Head of the Department
of International Law, Academic Director of the Research Institute
of Kutafi n Moscow State Law University (MSAL), Dr. Sci. (Law),
Associate Professor, Moscow, Russia
USTYUKOVA Valentina Vladimirovna — Acting Head of
the Sector of Environmental, Land and Agricultural Law of
the Institute of the State and Law of the RAS, Dr. Sci. (Law),
Professor, Moscow, Russia
TSAY TSZYUN — Director of the Law Institute of Henan
University, Dr. Sci. (Law), Professor, Kaifen, the PRC
TSOPANOVA Indira Georgievna — Dean of the Law Faculty
of the Russian Customs Academy, Cand. Sci. (Law), Associate
Professor, Moscow, Russia
CHILSTEIN David — Professor of Law, Head of the Department
of Criminal Law at the University of Paris 1 Pantheon-Sorbonne,
Paris, France
SHCHEGOLEV Vitaliy Valentinovich — Head of the Department
of International Development Assistance and Interaction with
International Organizations of the Federal Agency for the
Commonwealth of Independent States, Compatriots Living
Abroad and International Humanitarian Cooperation, Dr. Sci.
(Politic.), Moscow, Russia
Editor-in-Chief of the Issue:
VOLODINA Svetlana Igorevna — Head of the Department of
Advocacy of the Kutafi n Moscow State Law University (MSAL),
VP of the Russian Federal Bar Association, Attorney, Саnd. Sci.
(Law), Associate Professor
The journal was registered by the Federal Service for Supervision of Communications,
Information Technology and Mass Media (Roskomnadzor) on 5 October 2016.
The Certifi cate of Mass Media Registration: PI No. FS77-67361
2311-5998
12 issues per year
Federal State Budgetary Educational Institution of Higher Education
“Kutafi n Moscow State Law University (MSAL)”.
9 Sadovaya-Kudrinskaya ul., Moscow, Russia, 125993
9 Sadovaya-Kudrinskaya ul., Moscow, Russia, 125993
Tel.: +7 (499) 244-88-88 (ext. 687)
E-mail: vestnik@msal.ru
Free price
The journal is distributed through “Press of Russia” joint catalogue
and the Internet catalogue of “Kniga-Servis” Agency
Subscription index: 40650. Journal subscription is possible from any month
Printed in Publishing Center of Kutafi n Moscow State Law University (MSAL)
9 Sadovaya-Kudrinskaya ul., Moscow, Russia, 125993
11.01.2021
Volume: 28,14 conventional printer’s sheets (17,08 author's sheets). Format: 84×108/16.
An edition of 150 copies. Digital printing. Off set paper
When using published materials of the journal, reference to “Courier of the Kutafi n Moscow State Law University (MSAL)”
is obligatory. Full or partial use of materials is allowed only with the written permission of the authors or editors.
The point of view of the Editorial Board may not coincide with the point of view of the authors of publications.
Editor
Proof-reader
Computer layout
11/2020
L. A. Munkueva
A. B. Rybakova
D. A. Belyakov
Стр.6
4
Слово к читателю ............................................................... 6
УНИВЕРСИТЕТСКАЯ ХРОНИКА ............................................... 8
АВТОРИТЕТНОЕ МНЕНИЕ
Володина С. И.
К вопросу об адвокатуре на современном этапе ............................ 27
ПРАВОВАЯ ПОЗИЦИЯ
Пилипенко Ю. С.
Злоупотребления правом со стороны адвокатов:
правовая позиция Конституционного
Суда РФ, Верховного Суда РФ и ЕСПЧ ...................................... 37
ВЕКТОР ЮРИДИЧЕСКОЙ НАУКИ
Гаврилов С. Н.
Формирование понятийно-терминологической основы
информационной (цифровой) экосистемы адвокатуры ..................... 44
Деханов С. А.
Свобода объединений (ассоциаций) как доминанта
организационно-правовых форм адвокатских образований ................. 54
Кручинина Н. В.
Адвокатский контроль в сфере защиты репродуктивных прав человека .... 62
Макаров С. Ю.
Правовое регулирование деятельности адвокатов
в соответствии с Дигестами Юстиниана ..................................... 67
Манова Н. С., Сибирцев Г. И.
Сущность и цели уголовно-процессуальной защиты ........................ 78
Поспелов О. В.
Пределы и вариативность использования цифровых форм (инструментов)
в адвокатуре и адвокатской деятельности: подходы и методы .............. 88
Тонков Е. Н.
Источники права в «российском правовом реализме» ...................... 96
Васяев А. А.
Адвокаты во главе государства ........................................... 105
Калачева Е. Н.
Проблемы назначения адвоката-защитника в уголовном
судопроизводстве и возможные пути решения: вызовы цифровизации ..... 112
Образовательная среда
Короткова П. Е.
Традиции и цифровые новации в обучении студентов профессии
адвоката на профильной кафедре в юридическом вузе ................... 124
Никулина И. А.
Риторическая подготовка в вузе как основа
профессиональной речевой практики адвоката ........................... 133
Юридическая практика
Анисимова Е. О.
К вопросу о единой базе данных дисциплинарной
практики адвокатских палат ............................................... 141
Калинин Р. Э., Баринов Е. Х., Комиссарова Я. В.
К вопросу об оспаривании защитниками заключений
экспертов по делам о ятрогенных правонарушениях ...................... 148
11/2020
Стр.7
5
Михеева И. Е.
Cудебное усмотрение при применении
судами принципа добросовестности ...................................... 158
Романова О. А.
Особенности работы адвоката по делам,
связанным с градостроительными правоотношениями ................... 166
Скабелина Л. А.
Психологическая экспертиза детско-родительских отношений
с применением цифровых инструментов в адвокатской практике ......... 174
Халиков А. Н.
Следственные ошибки по делу
об изнасиловании в адвокатской практике ................................ 182
НАУЧНЫЙ ПОИСК
Ершова И. В., Петраков А. Ю., Цимерман Ю. С.
Доктрина инновационного права на службе цифрового права ............ 191
Белых В. С., Болобонова М. О., Коньков К. А.
Проблемы и перспективы определения доминирующего
положения в условиях цифровой экономики .............................. 202
ТРИБУНА МОЛОДОГО УЧЕНОГО
Германова А. А.
Функционирование институтов адвокатуры и нотариата в Германии ...... 211
Коган М. И.
Обеспечение сохранения адвокатской тайны при использовании
адвокатом современных технологий и электронных девайсов ............ 218
Соловьева Ю. И.
Анализ опыта регулирования правового статуса адвоката
в Федеративной Республике Германия с позиций возможности
его использования в Российской Федерации .............................. 224
Черных А. В.
К вопросу об инициировании оказания российским адвокатом
юридической помощи в процессе международного усыновления ......... 234
ПРАВО В ИСТОРИЧЕСКОМ ПРЕЛОМЛЕНИИ
Памятники права
Указ Правительствующему сенату ........................................ 239
Учреждение судебных установлений (извлечение) ........................ 240
Юридическое наследие
Чубинский М. П.
К вопросу о пределах свободы адвокатского слова ........................ 249
Из периодики прошлого
Гессен И. В.
Ахиллесова пята адвокатской этики ....................................... 254
ПОСТСКРИПТУМ
На досуге
С. П. Векшин
Адвокаты на дворе! (Сцена петербургской жизни в одном действии) ..... 259
11/2020
Стр.8