Российская академия наук
Сибирское отделение
ГУМАНИТАРНЫЕ НАУКИ В СИБИРИ
Серия: Философия и право
№ 1, 2009 г.
ФИЛОСОФИЯ И МЕТОДОЛОГИЯ НАУКИ
Целищев В.В. История тезиса Черча ....................................................................................................................................................3
Головко Н.В. Д. Дэвидсон, инструментализм и необходимость теории указания .........................................................................8
Карпович В.Н. Понятие истины и логическая онтология .............................................................................................................. 12
Симанов А.Л. Наблюдаемость, простота, толерантность и понятийный аппарат в физике ..................................................... 16
ИСТОРИЯ ФИЛОСОФИИ
Горан В.П. Кризис древнегреческой демократии и философия Сократа (IV) ............................................................................ 24
Любутин К.Н., Кондрашов П.Н. Три модели исторического процесса в философии истории Карла Маркса ..................... 31
СОЦИАЛЬНАЯ ФИЛОСОФИЯ И СОЦИОЛОГИЯ
Бобров В.В. Возвращаясь к предмету социальной философии ..................................................................................................... 38
Изгарская А.А. Пространство социальных отношений в миросистемном и геополитическом аспектах ............................... 42
Шмаков В.С., Сердюкова Ю.С. К проблеме моделирования социальных процессов ............................................................... 46
Цибриенко Р.Я. Методологические проблемы исследования адаптационных процессов
в обществе глобальных трансформаций ..................................................................................................................................... 50
Ермаханова С.А. Развитие представлений о социокультурных аспектах модернизации в социологии ................................. 55
Бодрякова Е.А. Методологические аспекты интерпретации понятия качества в экономической теории .............................. 60
Мархинин В.В., Удалова И.В. Демографические процессы и межнациональные отношения в Югре ................................... 64
Мусийчук М.В. Коммуникативный механизм юмора через призму иронии как приема остроумия ........................................ 68
ПРАВО И ФИЛОСОФИЯ ПРАВА
Дидикин А.Б. Историко-правовые предпосылки формирования науки государственного
(конституционного) права в России ............................................................................................................................................ 73
Черненко А.К. Инновация как способ формирования современной российской правовой системы ...................................... 77
Марков Ю.Г. Хозяйство будущего: право коллективной собственности ..................................................................................... 81
Нечаева Ю.В. Формирование структуры органов местного самоуправления:
проблемы реализации конституционного принципа самостоятельности ............................................................................. 86
Цихоцкий А.В. Процессуальное принуждение в гражданском судопроизводстве ...................................................................... 89
Лисица С.В. Допуск иностранных лиц к осуществлению инвестиционной деятельности ...................................................... 94
Бухтоярова О.А. Право на иск в защиту интересов неопределенного круга лиц ...................................................................... 98
Зыков С.В. Отличимость как критерий объектов интеллектуальных прав ................................................................................ 103
Чернусь Н.Ю. Гражданско-правовой оборот археологических находок .................................................................................... 106
НАУЧНАЯ ЖИЗНЬ. РЕЦЕНЗИИ
Вольф М.Н. Рецензия на кн.: Mourelatos, Alexander P.D. The Route of Parmenides: revised and expanded edition;
with a new introduction, three supplemental essays, and an essay by Gregory Vlastos (originally published 1970).
Las Vegas: Parmenides Pub., 2008. lix, 408 p. .............................................................................................................................110
Политика и право: проблемы интеграции и пути их решения. II Международная
научно-практическая конференция ............................................................................................................................................113
Summary .................................................................................................................................................................................................114
СОДЕРЖАНИЕ
© Сибирское отделение РАН, 2009
© Издательство СО РАН, 2009
Стр.1
ВСЕРОССИЙСКИЙ НАУЧНЫЙ ЖУРНАЛ
“ГУМАНИТАРНЫЕ НАУКИ В СИБИРИ”
Издается с января 1994 г.
Выходит четыре раза в год
У ч р е д и т е л и: Сибирское отделение РАН;
Институт истории СО РАН
РЕДАКЦИОННЫЙ СОВЕТ
Чл.-кор. РАН В.А.Ламин (председатель совета, Новосибирск), чл.-кор. РАН Б.В.Базаров (Улан–Удэ),
чл.-кор. РАН В.И.Бойко (Новосибирск), канд. ист. наук Н.М.Екеева (Горно-Алтайск), д-р техн. наук
Б.С.Елепов (Новосибирск), канд. ист. наук В.Д.Март-оол (Кызыл), д-р филол. наук Л.Г.Панин (Новосибирск),
академик РАН Н.Н.Покровский (Новосибирск), д-р филол. наук В.А.Роббек (Якутск),
чл.-кор. РАН Е.К.Ромодановская (Новосибирск), д-р ист. наук Н.А.Томилов (Омск), д-р ист. наук
В.Н.Тугужекова (Абакан), д-р филос. наук В.В.Целищев (Новосибирск)
РЕДКОЛЛЕГИЯ
Главный редактор д–р ист. наук В.А.Ильиных
Ответственный секретарь д-р ист. наук Н.Н.Аблажей
Д-р ист. наук Н.А.Алексеев, чл.-кор. РАН А.Е.Аникин, канд. филол. наук Э.А.Бальбуров, д-р ист. наук
А.В.Бауло (зам. гл. редактора), канд. филол. наук Б.В.Болдырев, д-р ист. наук Ф.Ф.Болонев, д-р ист.
наук С.С.Букин, д-р филос. наук В.П.Горан (зам. гл. редактора), д-р филос. наук А.А.Гордиенко, д-р ист.
наук Н.С.Гурьянова, д-р филос. наук В.Н.Карпович, д-р ист. наук С.А.Красильников, д-р филол. наук
Е.Н.Кузьмина, д-р ист. наук В.Е.Ларичев, канд. филол. наук А.А.Мальцева, д-р филос. наук
Ю.В.Попков, д-р ист. наук А.Л.Посадсков, канд. филол. наук Е.Н.Проскурина, д-р ист. наук Д.Я.Резун,
д-р филос. наук А.Л.Симанов, д-р юр. наук А.В.Цихоцкий, д-р ист. наук М.В.Шиловский, д-р филол.
наук Н.Н.Широбокова (зам. гл. редактора), д-р ист. наук В.И.Шишкин (зам. гл. редактора)
А д р е с р е д а к ц и и : 630090 Новосибирск, ул. Николаева, 8,
Институт истории СО РАН,
к. 301, тел. 333–24–37. http://www-psb.ad-sbras.nsc.ru
ablazhey@history.nsc.ru
З а в. р е д а к ц и е й Смирнова Вера Ивановна
Журнал зарегистрирован в Министерстве печати и информации РФ 17.06.93, №0110807
Редактор В.И.Смирнова
Компьютерная верстка и макет обложки Г.Я.Симановой
Подписано к печати 20.03.09. Формат 60 х 84 1/8. Офсетная печать.
Усл. печ. л. 14,5. Уч.–изд. л. 15. Тираж 700 экз. Заказ № 93.
Издательство СО РАН, 630090 Новосибирск, Морской проспект, 2
Стр.2
114
Гуманитарные науки в Сибири. № 1. 2009 г.
SUMMARY*
Tselischev V.V. History of Church’s Thesis
Church’s thesis is considered from the historical point of view.
It is shown that the initial version of the thesis was offered in
connection with λ-calculus, and only later was substantiated with
reference to the Turing machine.
Key words: Church’s thesis, Turing machine, axiomatic method,
problem of calculability, formal system, recursiveness.
Golovko N. D.Davidson, Instrumenalism and Need for
Reference.
Davidson’s position on the need of an explanatory
correspondence notion of truth is always interesting primarily because
of its reliance to the central problems of semantic realism. Davidson
gives truth the central role in semantics, he uses Tarski-style truth
theory and deflationary notion of truth but deny any place to theory
of reference. The paper shows that Davidson’s position may be seen
as unacceptable instrumentalism about reference. So his conception
is simple not interesting for those who interested in the development
of semantic realism.
Key words: D.Davidson, Principle of Charity, Principle of
Rationality, semantics without reference.
Karpovich V.N. The concept of truth and logical ontology.
Philosophers of various persuasions were concerned to
investigate the ontology of truth. That is, they were interested in the
extent to which one needed to assume the existence of entities serving
some role in accounting for the truth of sentences. Certain of these
entities were conceived as the bearers of the properties of truth and
falsehood. But instead of, or in addition to, truth-bearers, one must
assume the existence of certain entities in virtue of which sentences
and/or propositions are true. Any entities which are candidates for
this role are called truth-makers. The paper argues that the ontology
of truth can be conceived as situational in the sense that truth-makers
are specially and temporally determined.
Key words: logic, ontology, truth, concept, proposition, truthbearers,
truth-makers, situation.
Goran V.P. The Crisis of Democracy in Ancient Greece
and the Philosophy of Socrates (IV).
In order to draw near the solution of the question concerning
the political motivation of the trial on Socrates, the manifestations of
the hostile attitude to the philosopher before the trial are investigated.
The special attention is paid to the fact that contents of the indictment
against Socrates coincides with the image of the philosopher by
Aristophanes in his comedy “The clouds”.
Key words: Socrates, the trial on Socrates, the contents of the
indictment, Aristophanes, the comedy “The clouds”, the political
motivation of the trial on Socrates.
Lyubutin K.N., Kondrashov P.N. Three Models of Historical
Process in Marx’s Philosophy of History
In analysis K. Marx's philosophy of history the authors point
out that in Marx’s theory, along with social-production (materialistic)
conception of history, there is existential interpretation of the history
in which the historicity is the gradual movement from the universal
toil [die Arbeit] through the class division of toil and delight to the
total prevalence of the spontaneous action [die Selbstbetдtigung]
that is characterized by the freedom and the delight.
Key words: Marxism, materialist conception of history,
historicity, praxis, labor (toil), spontaneous action, delight, existential
interpretation of the history.
Izgarskaya A. The Space of Social Relations in the WorldSystem
and Geopolitical Aspects
This article is devoted to the research of the space of social
relations using the approaches of contemporary geopolitical theory
and a world-system analysis. As a result, the author offers typology
of spaces of social relations and a theoretical toolkit for analysis of
societies belonging to different world-system levels.
Key words: geopolitical advantages, geopolitical disadvantages,
levels of world-system.
Shmakov V. S., Serdjukova J. S. To the problem of modeling
of social processes: methodological aspects
In clause the analysis of modern social and economic
development of village is given, opportunities of mathematical
modelling of social processes are considered. At mathematical
modelling use of a method of imitating modelling with application
imitating многоагентной is offered to model.
Key words: social adaptation, social processes, mathe-matical
modelling.
Tsibrienko R. Methodological problems of analysis of
adaptation processes at the society of global transformations
The system approach, offered the author constructed on unity
philosophical, sociological and sinergetical of principles of
knowledge of a nature and a society, is used by the researcher for
Стр.122
Summary
the analysis of poly-subjective space adaptation of activity,
development of process virtualization of conditions of functioning
mezzo systems and its influence on the scripts of adaptive
behaviour of the people which have been switched on in
organizational interaction.
Keywords: A system methodology; a unity of universal,
particular and individual; double measuring of social processes;
general tendencies of modern development; the social methods of
management; subjects of adaptation; specializing orga-nizations;
virtue adaptations.
Yermakhanova S.А. Regarding the conception development
about sociocultural aspects of modernization.
This article views modernization as a complex process that has
quantity perspectives and components, including sociocultural aspect.
On the basis of literature review it is concluded that transformation
in scholars’ opinions regarding the modernization process over the
last two centuries. Nowadays these opinions contain more
sociocultural components. The results of socio-logical polls which
were carried out on the territory of Kazakhstan in 2006 revealed the
presence of a quantity of national cultures, inconsistency of different
value systems in social groups leaving an imprint on the character,
substance and rate of modernization processes. This makes the
development of universal strategy problematic which would be
equally suitable for all groups of population.
Keywords: modernization theory, modernization, culture,
sociocultural modernization, models of modernization.
Bodryakova E.A. Methodological aspects of inter-pretation
of the term «quality» by economic theory
In this article the basic concepts of quality for the purpose
of finding-out of scientific validity of the economic works
providing solutions to important applied problems of an estimation
of quality in economic practice are stated. Conclusions about
limitation of separate theories of quality, applied models and
techniques of an estimation of quality are substantiated. In
interpretation of the term "quality" by the economic theory the
author reveals essential contradictions. It is recognized, that the
basic gnoseological obstacle in practical use by the economic
theory of a philosophical category "quality" is the impoverished
theoretical maintenance of the economic term "quality", depriving
an economic object of the necessary and sufficient quantitative
definiteness. Theoretical enrichment of the substance of the category
"quality" is offered to implement by means of the philosophical
criticism of a principle of understanding of quality as static substance
of essence. The problem of research the quality as the process
providing all variety of functioning of an economic reality is set.
Keywords: quality, substence, estimation methods, criteria,
economic quality, philosophical quality, process.
V.V. Markhinin, I.V. Udalova. Demographic processes
and inte-rethnic relations in Khanty-Mansi Autonomous
Okrug – Yugra.
On basis of statistics and sociological research data the
authors review demographic processes (natural and migration
115
population increase) in Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug –
Yugra and their influence on interethnic relations. It is being
shown that the demographic situation in Yugra and interethnic
relations are determined by the policy of “radical reforms” in the
country and peculiarities of economic development in Yugra. The
authors discover tendency of constant decrease of Russian and
Slavic population share in Okrug, which is the ground of
interethnic tension increase.
Key words: interethnic relations, migration and demographic
processes.
Musijchuk M.V. The communicative mechanism of humour
through the prism of reception of wit «irony»
The summary is considered the communicative mechanism
of hu-mour on the basis of reception of wit «irony». The
communicative mecha-nism of humour is a change of sense as a
result of connection of various words or expressions of relatives
on sounding, construction, value. Lan-guage has effective forms
of change of sense in the course of perception. It is a basis of the
communicative mechanism of humour.
Keywords: the Communicative mechanism of humour,
reception of wit «irony», communicative интенция, communicative
modalities, semantic perception of humour.
Didikin A.B. The historical and legal grounds of the
forming constitutional legal science in Russia.
The paper attempts to analyze the historical and legal aspects
of the forming of Russian constitutional legal science. The political
situation and its influence to Russian system of legal science and
education con-cerning the problems of the conceptual grounds
and methodology of the constitutional legal theory are considered.
The author suggests the new approach to the legal historical
research introduced to analyze the external and internal factors
of development of constitutional legal science.
Key words: constitutional legal science, constitutionalism,
consti-tutional projects.
Chernenko A.K. Innovation as a tool of forming the modern
Russian legal system.
The paper attempts to analyze the genetic nature of the
modern innovational process in Russian legal system. The
problem situation and its crisis aspects in the Russian legal
science concerning the problems of the conceptual grounds
and methodology of the legal theory, classification and criteria
of the legal creation are considered. The author suggests
the genetic approach to the legal innovations introduced to
analyze the internal logic of self-determination of the legal
phenomena’s.
Key words: innovation, legal creation, levels of the legal system.
Markov U.G. The economy of the future: of right collective
property
Work is dedicated to the problem of the selection of the
prevailing right of property in the economic system of Russia. It
is shown that the economy of future, will be most likely, built
Стр.123
116
within the framework collective property, to be more precise, of
general longitudinal property. For this form of property one must be
prevailing, since it not only in the best way considers the interests of
working people, but also it corresponds to the historical values of
Russia, to its sociocultural basis. In the article the presented facts,
which confirm thought about the high efficiency of the cooperative
economies, based on collective property of participants.
Keywords: right, property, cooperative economies.
Nechayeva Yu.V. Formation of the structure of local
authorities: Problems of realization of the constitutional principle
of independence
The article discusses the question of ‘controversies’
between the Federal norms and the existing situation at the
level of municipalities. A conclusion is made about adoption of
a statute regulating issues of forming a control authority of the
municipal entity.
Key words: local government, municipal institution, local
authorities.
Tsihotskiy A.V. The Procedural Enforcement in Civil
Procedure
The issues of enforcement in civil procedure in the mechanism
of legal guaranteeing of justice’s efficiency are considered. It is proved
that enforcement in civil procedure is a part of social reality, the
existential phenomenon, which situated in complex mutual relations
with different parties of legal procedure and legal sense of procedural
participants. Mentioned phenomenon is aimed at making
preconditions for achievement of justice’s purposes.
Keywords: Law, legal procedure, illegal behavior, remedial
compul-sion, responsibility measures, law and order measures of
protection, preven-tive measures.
Lisitsa V. N. The Admission of Foreign Persons to
Investment Activity
In the article the concept of admission of foreign investors
to invest-ment activity is related to granting them the right on
business and other activity in territory of the accepting state and
is expressed, first of all, in es-tablishment of restrictions and
additional duties imposed on them (in compa-rison with the
citizens of the state). The state independently carries out the legal
regulation of foreign investments and, in particular, determines
at own discretion, on what conditions the foreign investors can
begin to carry out their activity in its territory.
Depending on the character of participation of the state, by
analogy to the ways of creation of a legal person it is offered to
Гуманитарные науки в Сибири. № 1. 2009 г.
distinguish three forms of admission of foreign investors:
authorization, reviewing, and noti-fication order.
Key words: International law; investment law; regulation of
investment activity.
Bukhtoyarova O.A. The right to lay an action defending
public interests
The research work investigates (analyses) the right to lay an
action defending public interests in the civil procedure. It is being
proved that justice in the case with a multiple (numerous) group of
persons (know as well under the term of «a non-fixed circle of
persons») is open to general use. The rights and duties of the public
prosecutor and state power organs of control are being observe with
the purpose of defending the rignts, freedoms and legal interests of
other persons.
Key words: law, justice, public interests, the right to lay an
action, a non-fixed circle of persons, the defend of the human rights,
civil procedure.
Zykov S.V. Distinguishability as a Standard of Objects
of Intellec-tual Rights
The objects of intellectual rights as material objects have no
direct grounds in sensual reality.
The author divides criteria for individualization of the results
of intel-lectual activity into general and specific. In a few theoretical
research papers the universal criterion was identified as a novelty
standard. The author argued over this conception because of its
possiblesubjective interpretation. The term “distinguishability” is
offered and universality of this term is proved: it can be correlated
not only with legal features of the results of intellectual activity, but
also with means of individualization of legal persons, goods, work
and services.
Key words: intellectual property, objects of intellectual property,
novelty [of the invention].
Chernus N.Y. The legal regulation of a cultural value’s
civil turn.
The problem of legal regulation of a civil turn of cultural values
always concerned and concerns to number actual for civil sciences
and experts. It is connected, first, by there are no monographic
researches of a civil turn of cultural values, secondly, the legislation
regulating a turn of such values, contains a number of blanks and
contradictions. Article is devoted to features of a legal regime of an
archeological find.
Key words: archeological find, cultural values, historical
values.
Стр.124