III.
KP AHIOJIOrHqECROE COEP AHIE.
(Coo6~eHO A. n. Bor)J;RHOBJdM'L).
KpaHio.J:ornqecKoe co6panie 06m,ecTBa .[ro6nTe.mH: EcTecTBOSHaHi.a
Ha1J3..110 OpraHHSOBaT.bCJI C'.b 1865 ro.n;a. llepBhlM'.b BK.:IIa)l;OM'.b
6:r:.um ,n;Ba qepena H3'.b RypraHOB'.b Ilo.n;o.ilb~Raro yts.n;a, MoCROBCKon
ry6epHiH, rrpHHeCeHHhle B'.b ,J;ap'.b 06m,eCTBY A. A. raTII;JltOM'.b
II B036J,J;IIBillie 3HalJUT6.l.bHhlli liHTepeC'.b CBOUM'.b ptSRO
BhlpaJKeHHhlM'.b ,li,OJlHXOII;elfla.mqecKmi'.b TJIIIOM'.b, IIpOTIIBOptlJHBillHM'.b
pt3KO Tt.M'.b o6m,errpHHHThlM'.b MHtHiJIM'.b, KOH cym,eCTBOBa.m
,li,O TOfO OTHOCHTe.lbHO .J.OIICTOpllqecN.aro HaCe.IeHiJI II;eHTpa.1.bHOli
Pocciu. B'.b 1866 r. u 181)8 ro.n;y 6hl.lll saTtM'.b nponsBe.n;enJ.I
MHOIO, 1I IIO MOefi npOC.b6t HtKOTOphlMll H3'.b MOHX'.b COTOBapurn,efi,
snalJJITe.ThHhlJI pacKomm, pesy.ll.bTaT'.b ROHX'.b 6hl .. 1'.b
npe,n;cTaB.IeH'h na (hnorpalflnqecKyro BhlCTaBity 1867 ro.n;a, KaK'.b
B'.b BH,n;t KO.il.leKII;ili ROCTJIKOB'.b li KypraHHhlX'.b npe,n;MeTOB'.b, TaK'.b
ll B'.b op:ut OC06aro COl£HHeHiJI, IIOCBJllll,eHHaro KpaHiO.JIOriH MoCKOBCKaro
~typrannaro napo.n;onace.Jienia. 3aTt~I'.b .n;o 1876 ro.n;a
RO.JI.leRII,iJI IIO He,li;OCTaTKY cpe,n;CTB'.b o6oram,a.;raC.b TO.ll.bKO C.lyqafiHO,
XOTJI 1i JBe.JIHl£li.JiaC.b HtCKO.llbKIIMli 3aJntl£aTe.ll.bHhlMH cepiJIMI1
qepenOB'h, KaiWBhi, naupmrBp'.b, H3'h HoBropo,n;cKHX'.b .iKa.JibHHKOB'.b
OT'.b f. B 0 .1K e HIll Tell H a, li3'.b HOBrOpo,n;eKIIX'.b MOfH.ll'.b Ot'.b
A. M. P aeBCK o.H, Ka.JMIJII,Kie OT'.b npolfleceopoB'.b )leera~f~Ta
H Ba.nTepa, II u:nKo.JIOllleHeKIIX'.bKypraHOB'.b OT'.bA.M.AnaeTae.beBa.
TO.IbKO B'.b 1876 ro,n;y, KOr,n;a eHOBa IIO,J;HJIT'.b 6hl.JI'.b BOnpOC'L
o6'.b AHTporro.JoriPieeKoii BhleTaBKt n JIBH.JIIIe.b epe,:~;cTBa,
B03MOatHO 6hl.IO eHOBa IIplleTyiiiiTb K'.b eiieTeMaTHl£eeKOMY _ IIOIIO.IHeHiiO
KO.l.leKII;iii: B'.b Tpll .ltTa ,J;06hlTO 6hl.IO 3Hal£ll'.(e.ll.bHOe
lJHe.IO qepeiiOB'.b, Morym.nx'.b U:Mt'l'.b eep.b03Hlilfl IIHTepee'.b IIO CBOe:My
HaylJHOMY 3Hal£eHiiO, KaK'.b Heii3C.lt;I;OBaHHhlll eJ:n;e )~0 HaeTOam.aro
BpeMemr MaTepia.l'.b.
.KpaHi0.10l'IPieCKOe eo6paHie, COCTUB.IHIOm.ee O;J.IIH'.b 113'.b eaMhlX'.b
6oraThlX'.b OT,II,t.IOB'.b BhlCTaBKU, rrpe,;I;eTaB.JIJieT'.b eym,eeTBeHHIDJ
HHTepeC'.b TO.I.bKO ,.l,.lJI Cllell,ia.:IIICTOB'.b, TaK'.b KaK'.b OHO MO.iK6T'.b
,n;aTh JIM'.b HOBhlJI ,JI,aHHhlH ,JI,.JIH nx'.b nse.Jit,n;oBanill. BnpolleM'.b
Hafi,n;eTeJI B'.b co6paHiu HtCKOJThKO lJeperrOB'.b, KOH rre 6e3'.bHHT6peeHhl
B006m.e ;II;.JIJI llOCi>TUTe.Jiefi BhleTaBKII, KaK'.b He 6e3'.bHHTepeCHO
,li,.JIJl HHX'.b MOJK6T'h 6hlTIJ o6m.ee 3HaKOMCTBO e'.b eoeTaJlOM'.b
eo6paniJI u c'.b :u;t.liiDHI, KOII .Jier.Jin B'.b ero oenoBy. CoBpeMennaa
Kpanio.JioriJI Bos6ym)l;aeT'.b snalJliTe.ll.bHJilli 11HTepee'.b, KaK'.b
Ti>MH Ha)l;eJK,ll;aMH, KOTOphlH B03.JiaraiOTeH Ha Hee llpHBepmen:u;aM11
ea, TaK'.b 11 TtMH narra,li,KaMH na nee, KO~'ll ona no.n;BepraeTeJI
OT'.b eBOHX'.b llpOTIIBHIIKOB'.b, ,ii;OXO,ll,~llX'.b II0l£TH )1;0 liO.iiHaro OTpnn;aHiJI
BeJIKaro naywaro sna11enia eJI. llpul!HHhl TaKIIX'.b npoTnByrro.IOmHhlX'.b
B3f.IJl,ii;OB'.b .Jie1KaT'.b KaK'b B'.b ca:\IOH eym.HOeTH
MaTepia.;ra, e.ily.iKam.aro oenoBoro ,n;.IJI Kpanio.mrin, TaK'.b 11 B'.b
Ti>X'.b BHtlliHHX'.b ye.JIOBiJIX'.b, npll KOTOphlX'.b OHa pa3BHBa.Jiae.b H
pasBHBaeTea. BrrpolleM'.b oTpn:u;aTe.ll.bHLIM'.b Bospi>HiJIM'.b RpaHio.JioriJI
IIO,JJ,BepraeTCJl IDl 6o.ll.bme, HH MeH.bme, RaR'.b II Bet BHOB.b
q.opMHpyrom.iaeJI nayRII, nMtrom,iJI nepe,n;'.b eo6oro RpaH:ne mnpoRi.a
sa,11,a1JH H paeno.:mrarom.ia Rpaiine eRy,ii;HhlM'.b MaTepia.JIOM'.b. B'.b
eBOe BpeMa II apxeO.IOrii, II .IIIHl'BHeTmta, H ,J;Wite BCS: 300.101'11qeeKaH
Moplflo.lloria, nepemHBa.m TaKoli z.e THZenrlt A-IJI BBnt
nepio,n;'.b. KTo ne lJIITa.JI'.b pa3.lJlllDIHX'.b Ryp.bOSHHX'L npBllipOB'J.
OTHOellTe.I.bHO 41H.liO.JIOl'H1JeeRHX'.b epaBHeBift: H llpOHSBO,I;CTBa C.IOB'L,
KTO B'.b 6woe BpeM.H He llO,li;TpJHHBa.li'L Ha,li;'L Otl'LJICHeHien, Ap6BHIIX'.b
na;~;liHeeii H na.n;'.b omn6Ra:MH apxeo~oroB'L? D;'.k.ILIJ[ noB'.keTH
li pOMaHhl liOeBJilii;a.JIHe.b OeMtJIHi.Io CTp&cTH apxeO~OfOB'L, HO
BeJIKifi 3HaeT'.b, lJTO Bet 3TH r.liJM.lleHiJI He Hll'.k.llH BliRaROfO BpeJJ;Haro
B.lliania na eaMyiO naJKy n ne HO,li;OpBa.m eJI SHalleHia:
nanpoTHB'L, e'.b Ram,n;LIM'L ro)I.OM'.b yeoBepmeHeTBy.a cBol IeTOJflt,
o6oralll,aHe.b HOBLDI'.b MaTepia.JIOM'.b, ORa K'L CllaCTiiO CTaHOBHTCB
Bee Rptrr1
Ie H Rptrrqe II nalfl111aen s8JDDlaT.b no.n;o6a10~ee el
no eBoeMy sHalleniro Bhl,li,arom.eee.a MteTo. Toze Heemm'.kHHo 6y,II;eT'.b
H e'.b KpaHiO.JIOrieiO, XOTJI 6hl llOTOMJ, liTO 6eS'L H6JI Helllle.JIHMO
,li,a.JI.bHtfooee ptmenie MHOl'HX'L BOnpOeOB'L.
JieTOpiJI OeTaBJUa HaM'.b JRa3aHi.H Ha MHOria ll~eJieH&, HriBllli.H
B'.b eBOe BpeMJI 3HalJHTe.ll.bHOe BJiiJIHie Ha eOeTaB'L B pasBHTie
pas.rnl£HhlX'.b nan;ionannoeTeit EBpoHJ:J. B'L Poecill liJl BC'k
roBopnM'.b o Tio.llaHax'L, o ,ll;peB.liJIHax'L, CRnlflax'L, llo~oBu;ax'L u
.n;pyrHx'L, no RpoMt HMeH'.b .n;o noerl.n;naro BpexeHH M1ii 11&10
lJTO 3Ha.nl 06'.b 3TIIX'L 06HTaTe.IJIX'.b, TaK'L RaR'L DTOllHCH OCTaBH.UI
HaM'.b TO.llhRO He3HalJHTe.ll.bHLIJI H3BteriJI 0 BH'.kiHHefi ,I;UTe.ILHOeTU:
3THX'.b ll.lleMeH'.b H liOlJTH HH1Jero 0 HX'L HpOHCXO~eHiH, 0
nx'.b xpoBHoll: eBJI3II e'.b .n;pyrHMH ll.lleMeHa.Mu:.. Ee.m D;HC:&IeBBlile
naMJITHHRU: ,ll;aiOT'L TaK'.b Ma.JIO ,ll;.liJI HeTopill nepBOHalla.ILH&rO nepio,a;a
napo,n;aHaee.lleHia Poeeiu H 3ana,n;Hoft EBpoHLI H ec.m nosnaHie
3TIIX'.b HapO,li;OB'.b O,li,HO TO.llbRO B'L eOeTOmrlB: Otl'LJlCBJITI.
HaM'.b BliO.iiHt HaJllHO ,JI;a.il.bHtfimi.a ey,li,.b6Iil 3THX'L HapO)(OHaC616HID,
3aBIIetBmiJI OT'.b· HX'.b 4lH3H1JeeRHX'L eBOHCTB'L H OtlCTa.HOBKH,
TO OlJeBH,li;HO HeH30tZ.HiilM'.b JIB.liJieTeJI H3Jll6IDe, llO)(p06HOe H
TOlJHOe, Beero TOrO, liTO OT'.b HHX'.b OeTa.IOe.b. 3TO OCTaBmeeea
BLipamaeTeJI B'L MOrWiaX'.b, B'.b llOrpe6eHHLIX'L B'L HHX'L ROCTHKaX'.b,
B'.b HaXO,li;HMiiiX'L B'.b HHX'.b npe,n;MeTaX'.b. flORa HeTopi.Jo noHIIMa.liii
TO.ll.bRO RaK'.b .JitTOHHe.b BHtillHHX'.b C06Il'riil: B BORa BHTepeeOBa.JIHe.b
TO.ll.bKO HapO)I.aMH, 3aHJIB:rrnnm: BH,n;HOe H B.lli.Jnom.ee
MteTo B'.b nomTHlJeeROM'.b pa3BHTin roey.n;apeTB'L, )I.O rlx'L nop'L
oTeyTeTBie eBt.n;tniii o TeMHhlX'.b oonxaTe.ll.aX'.b .n;peBntilmaro nepio.n;a
Ma.JIO oeSllOROJUO JlleHLIX'L H HHeRO.ll.bRO He BHTepeeOB&IO
ny6.JIIIRy. ,lJ;o HaeTo~aro eTOrlTiJI He TO.llbRO napO,JUl HelleSBJBmie
H oeTaBHBmie Ma.JIO e.llt.JJ;OB'L B'L HeTOpill M3.10 ROfO BHT&peeOBa.illl,
no ;~;ame nepBo6LITHLie uapo,li;Iil, HLIHt atHByntie, 38JIHMa.m
,II;a.JieRo He BH,n;Hoe MteTo B'.b PHAY lJe~oBtlJeeRHX'L sHa.Hilt.
,lJ;HRapiDlll BHTepeeOBa.JIHe.b H.JIH RaR'L RJPL030li'L B'L lle~OB'.klleeKOM'.b
po,n;t, H.liH RaK'.b MaTepia.liOM'.b ,li,.JIJI 9Rerr.liJaTau;ill. flyTemeeTBeHHiiRaMII
eo6paHo owo MHoro .n;aHHiilX'L o HX'L
6m,
npaBaX'.b H o6Iil1JaJIX'.b, HO Bee 9TO eOCTaBJIJLIO CLipOillaTepi&I'L,
ne no,n;BeprHyTLiii eTporoU: nay'IHoii RpHTHR'.k, He noAJ~e)(eHHRI
IIO)I.'L HaJlJHYIO eHeTeMJ. ll09TOMJ TaK'L )1.0.11'0 H He HapOZ)(&IOC:L
1
Стр.1
2TOH
nayn.H, I:WTopaJI nocn1> reo:epn nasBanie AnrponoJrorirr; rroBTOliY
TaKJKC )I;O.lrOe BpeMJI H a}JXeO.IOria He MOr.Ia 3a£IJITI> IIpHHa,J,.Ieatarn;ee
eli MtcTo. 8TH .n.sa Kpaey.Thnhle KaMHJI nlilrrtmrrn:ro
HCToprrqec&aro 3nanin:, II~Ienao ArrrponoJiorin: H ApxeoJiorin:, MOrJiu
HapO,li;UThCff B'n CBOefi BIIO.IHt nayWOH Ko B'D name BpeMn:, IIMenao B'L nepio)I;'T>
ecrecrBenrro-IIcropaqecKaro II.III reneriiqecKaro ru:ero,;~;a B'D
06'J>HCHeHiU JIBJienifr, He TO.IDI:W B'J> JUipt , HO H B'D
Kpyry IICTOplllleCKHX'D HBJieHili.
Kor,;~;a 6wo ,li;03Hano, l£TO reo.IoruqeCI'i.ia HBJrerrin: 3eJ'rrnoit Kophl
npe.n.craB.IHIOT'L pHA'D noc:li>,TJ;oBaTeJI£Ho pa3BnnaBmaxcn: II
B3aii?rfHO 06'LJCJIOBJIIIBaBilliiX'D JIBJl8HiU: II B'h CBOUX'D TO.lll~aX'h
IDiiliOT'D HCTOpiiO, He JCTJllalO~fiO B'D )I;OCTOBi>pHOCTll IIIICnMeHHhiM'D
llaMJITHl!Ka~1'D; ROf,ll;a OCBOllJiliCb C'D TOIO MliiCIDIOj lJTO opraHH3M'D
BCHitaro CJIII,eCTBa CTaHOBliTC.ll IlOHil'l'IIIDI'D TO.[f>.KO 'fOf)l;a,
KOr)l;a H3Bi>CTHa ero HCTOpi.a pa3BH'riJI H )1;03HaHhl Ti> rrpeBpau~eHi.H,
ROJIM'D OH'D nO)I;BepraeTCH; KOf)l;a BhlHCHHJIOCb 3HaqeHie
H BJii.arrie nJieJneHHiiiX'L oco6errnocTefi H artTOpOB'.b
na 6hlT'D H pa3BHTie napO;I:OB'D, TOr,.'l.a HCTOpiiO 'le.JOB'B"ll8CTBa
ne.IL3H yate 6IiLJio na•mua.n C'h nepio;J;a KY.JII>TYPHhlX'h napo)I.OB'L,
a HY,CXHO 6IiLJIO li)I;TH ,il.ll..lbllle, TaK'D .KaK'D TO.ilblW B'D 3TOM'D
nepBOHaqaJI])HOM'J> IIpOIDJlOM'D liOjji,HO 6.liL10 Half)I;TH KOpeHD K
HallaJIO )l;.liJI 06'J>JICHeHiJI IIOC.ili>,ll.yiOrn;aro. JlBIIJiaCh HayKa 0 ,;I;OIICTOpHqecKOM'J>
lJe.JIOBi>Kt, CKOpO no.qqHBmaa OC06eHHO Ba:amoe
3aaqenie B'I> Rpyry 3Hanill: coBpeuennaro qeJioBt.&a. Ho ,li;OHCTOpKllec.Idrr
lJe.llOBi>K'D HaXO,li.HJICH B'J> JC.IOBiJIX'J> aHaJIOfH'fHhlX'J> C'J>
HJ)IlrB JK.HBJIII,KMII nepB06hlTIIhiMH IUe.MeHaMII, B'J> KOTOphlX'D TOJIDltO
H MOJKHO 6hl.llO Hall)I;TH 06'J>JICHeHie MHOfOMJ TOMy, lJTO npe,li.CTaB.liJIJili
HaM'D )I;OHCTOpH'IeCKie HapO,ll;hl. 0TCIO)I;a yqenie 0 ,li;OHCTOpKqecKOM'J>
qeJIOBi>Kt Ti>CHO CB.H3UJIOCb C'J> y-qenieM'D 0 nepB06.hiTHhlX1>
ll.JieMeHaX'D II Bhl3BaJIO pa3BHTie HaJKH aHTpOIIOJIOriii,
)l.peBHeU 110 CBOel'IIY Ha3BaHiiO, HO COBeprneHHO COBpeMeHHOH HaM'D
ITO CBOeMy MeTO)I;y, no CBOHM'h ~tJIJIM'J> JI IIO CBOeMy 3Hal£eHiiO.
HcTopi.a, ,li.Ome,ll.mll ,11;0 y6t:at,ll.eHiJI B'D neo6xo)l;uuocru 03HaKoJriHThCJI
C'J> )I.OHCTOpllqeclUIMll HapO,ll;aMII II 113JqHTb HX'n C'D TOqKII
3pi>niJI rrepBOHalJaJinHiiiX'D aKTOpOB'J>, H3'D KOIIX'J> CJ10iKHJiaCI> noCJii>)l;yiOIIJ;a.ll
HCTOpiiqecKaH JltH3Hh HapO,li;OB'J>., He cpa3y o6paTHJiaCh
It'D J.llCHeHiiO 3Haqeni.ll aHTpOllOJIOrHqecKHX'J> )l;aHHhlX'D, a
nocrerrenno, no Htpt Kpaii:neii: HYJKAhl a ,ll;aiKe qacro noMIIMO
· CBOeH BO.liH. CHallaJia JlliHrBliCTIIlleCKi.a HaBe)l;eHiJI li cpaBHeHie
6:hiTOBIJX'J> rrpe,li;MeTOB'J> Ka3aJIHCb ,li.OCTaroqHii(Mll )I;JIJI pa3'DJICHeHiJI
Ti>X'L CBJI3eH, KOli CJIII,eCTBOBaJill MeJK)I;J ,li.OHCTOpHqecKHMH
napo)l;aMH. JlBIUC.Il npeJll.)l;e nepio,;r.1> JIIIIli'BliCTHllecKaro II apxeoJioroarnorpaaqecKaro
K3yqeniJI )I;OcropaqecKHX'D nJielren'D, ROTOphlrr
,li;OJirOe BpeMJI II IICKJliOqHTeJinHO rOCllO,li.CTBOBa.JI'D B'J> K.mccHH.JtaiJ,iii
qe.JOBi>qecitHX'h ITJieMeH'D. ()To 6IJJIO H nOIIJITHO: B'D C.lOBi>
H :B'D CBOHX'J> 6IJTOBIJX'J> npOJIBJieHi.llX'D BhlpamaeTCJI BCero 6o.;rte
lle.llOBi>K'D, KaK'J> cy~eCTBO CTOHm,ee 6e3rpaHJiqiiO Blalllle .'aiHBOTHaro
Mipa • .iKrrBOTHIJM'L pyKOBO,li.UT'L TO.InKO opraHH3a~i.ll, y "t!eJioBim.a
BJii.lliOT'D BIJcmia naqa.Ja. C.IOBO n OIJTn 6e3cnopno Ba'IKHIJ,
HO 9TOrO He ,li;OCTaToqao e~e J1, .. 111 CUeiJ,ia.JihHaro n03HaHiJI )I;OHCTOpH"tJ:eCRal'O
qeJIOBi>Ka 110 liHOl'lilf'J, II cy~eCTBeHHIDI'J> npHqHHartl'D.
BonepB:r.IX'D )I;03Hano, qto cy~ectBOBaJIH 11 B'D 3arra)l;noll: EBponrli,
R B'f• Poccin, nJielrena, RJ)TOphl.ll ne ocraBHJUI rro ce6t HHRaltHX'D
C.l'h/~08'1> Hll B'D Jl3IJKil, HU B'J> .KaKliX'D .m6o .J:OCTaTOlJHO
onpe.rr.·h.;rennux·J> 6IJTOBIJX'J. npe.a.Merax'h, 3a HCK.UOllerrieJI'D II3)I.i>.liii
UTI• Ka.MHJI H H3'h pOi'OB'L ll KOCtefi nUffiOTHLIX'h. Y TaKUX'.I)
ruelteH'L caltT:.Ul'L xapaRrepHcraqnwt'L JIB.merca TO.ThKO qepell'I,
H IWCT.Illi'I>. lJTO iKe OT6pOCIITb .111 9TII II.IC'KeHa, COCTaB.lJIIO~iH
nau6o.1te nepnorra•ra.Ii>HOe n3'L roro, 'Ito Mhl 3Hae~n o qe.JoBi>Kt,
11.111 iKe I.IOCTapaTbC.ll II:JB.Ie% H3'h n03HaHiJI J.WCTHJia BCe
to, qto OH'L liOi&et'l) ;I,aT»? Koaeqno nyiKno 6u.:1o npi£6tnryorn
K'D IIOc.rl;;.t.HeMJ, II BOT'L Upllt!IIHa JIOqe.My, HaK'L 6T:l He OTBCpra.m
3Haqenie KpaHiO.IOfill, OHa JIB~HCTCil He TO.Ih.KO O}J;HIIll'h 113'.1)
CIIOC060B'h II3C•lt;:J.OBaWJI ,:J.OIICTOpllqCCKa.ro qe.JOBt.Ka, HO ;~;a;.Re
C,;I;HHCTBeHHliiM'L HCTOqHIIK011'b AI1l U03HaHi11 caH:hiX'L UCJ)BllqHLIX'L
rueuen1>.
; Bo BTOphlx'.b; ITO OTHOllleHiiO 6o..rte HOBi>HlliKX'J> ll.ilelreH'D BCTptqaiOTCJI
C.1yqau, 1Wl')~a IIpli Indi>Hiii JliiHl'Bl:ICTH'leCI'i.liX'J> II apxeOJIOl'JiqecitllX'J>
)l;aHHiiiX'D, Rpanio.rrornqecKi.ll CBll;J;i>rencTBa 6hl.BaIOT'D
naamhl'. Hctopin: rroKa3IJBaeT'D, "t!TO HHOr)l;a nopa6orn;enn:r:.Ur
napO,li;'I> IIpiiHUMaer'D n JI3IaiK'D, II npaB'L ,ll.pyraro. B1> TaKHX'D c.llyl!a.ax'D
MOfH.Ihl ,li;OliCTOpJiqecKHX'D, IIJIII He liMi>IOJIJ,liX'D llHCn:MeHHOif
HCTOpiu, n.IeMeH'b, a TaKJKe OCTaBJieHHhl11 H:Mll B'D HaCJii>)I;CTBO
ru:i>CTHiiiJI Ha3BaHiJI MOI'JT'D IIOBeCTH K'b JIOjKHIJM'D BhlBO,ll;aM'D O'IHOCIITeJlhHO
IIJieMeHHhlX'J> CB.Il3eH. Bcero 6o.II'f;e ycrofiqiiBhlM'L
JIB.liJIIOTCJI B'D TaKliX'D CJIYqaJIX'D ITJie~IeHHhl.ll .H3II'leCKi.H qepThl,
BIJpazarorn;iJic.a B'D opMt qepeua, pocra, qepraxn .rn~a, :u It'D
TaKofr rroBi>pi:ti> Heo6xo,li.HMO Bcer)l;a npa6·£raTn .n.aJKe raM'.b, r,11;':h
yJKe cy~ecTBJIOT'n ntrwTopLI.a YAOBJieTBOpHtenHhlH ,ll.aiiHIJ.a o6'h
ncqe3HYBillliX'D HapO,ll.aX'b. HaKOl'Ie~'D OTHOCHTeJILHO HhlHi> cyrn;eCTBYIOIII,llX'D
HapO,li.OB'D, BCi>M'D H3Bi>CTHIJX'J> H 6oraThlX'D HCTOpieiO,
npiiXO,li.HTC.H BCe TaKII npn6traTh K'D KpaHiOJIOl'iH He3aBIICHMO OT'L
.li.PJfliX'h aHTpOITOJIOl'IneCKIIX'D 1\t:eTO)~OB'D lf:JCJii>,li.OBaHiJI. liTO TaKOe
tl>pa~y3hl, HtMII;hl, PyccKie? H3'D Ka&ux'J> a;reMeHTOB'I> oaa
CJIOifi.ll.illiCb II Be3)1;i> Jill Ha C.S.Oell TeppliTOpia OHH o6pa30Ba.J.lliCb
H3'1>
o,;~;nux·n a ri>x·r. JKe aJieMeHTOB'.b? Mnoro nauacaHo 6wo
npet&p;e 061> 9TOM'J> li3Jii>)I;OBaHiH, HO Bee Ta&H BOIIpOC'D IIO)I;BUHJJICJI
cymecTBeHHO TOJIDKO TOr)l;a, .KOr,ll,a npH6tr.iiH It'D aHTpOIIOJIOrHqecitOMJ
MeTOJ.Y li3CJii>)I;OBaHiJI.
TaKHM'D o6pa30M'h 3Haqenie ,li;OIICTOplltiecrmx'D II nJieMeHHIJX'r.
paC'D npe,li.CTaB.ilJieTC.H cy~ecTBeHHhll'l1'h He )I;JIJI O)~HOH TO.JIDIW
aHTpOnOJIOriH, HO ,li.JIJI ~tJial'O II;IIKJia IICTOpUqecKIIX'L IIayK'D, B1.
li3Bi>CTHhlX'J> OT.LI;i>JiaX'D IIX'h. 8TIIi)TaiKepKII Ha BliiCTaBKi> C'h 6peHHiiiMll
OCTaTKaMll qeJIOBi>Ka COCTaBJIJllOT'h KJI.IOt£'0 K'h llOHUMaHiiO ll pa3ptmeHiiO
1\IHOriiX'D BOllpOCOB'D, 1\t:OrymHX'b HHTepeCOBaTb Kant.n:aro.
8TO He rrpoauau,ir: OCTaTKOB'b lleJIOBi>Ka, a TOJlhKO B03se.n:enie HX'h
B'D llCTOpHlleCKie ,li.OKYJ\IeHTIJ, B'L 3Haqenie BaJKHi>llUIIIX'n naMJITIIlfltOB'J>
RCTOpia qeJIOBi>l[t}CTBa. ,If;o6pOAYillHOe, XOTJI H HeBiH.KeCTBeHHOe,
OTHOllleHie It'D )I;OIICTOpJiqeCKHM'h OCTaTKUM'h 'leJIOBtKa
6IJJIO npaqHHOIO TOrO, liTO MHOI'O Ir0l'H6JIO 1\t"aTepiaJia, HCB03BpaTHMaro
)I;JIJI HCTOplilla ·ll aHTpOllOJIOra. BliiCTaBlW, B036yJK)I;UJl
p.a)l;'h BorrpocOB'D no ornomeHiiO qepenoB'I, n y.acn.lur nx·n 3IIaqenie,
eCJIH He B'D o6meM'D, TO B'L qaCTHOCTJIX'h, C.lJjKaT'J> .LI;i>JIJ
nayKH H )l;a.ilhHi>HilleMy pa3BIITiiO "t!eJIOBima, XOTJI 6hl B'b TOM'h
OTHOilleHin, lJTO npiyqaiOT'D CMOTpi>Th Kail.i.,J;al'O C'n Bi>pHOii T01U\H
3pi>HiJI Ha npe,li;CTaB.IT.IliOmieC.ll e3IY .JI:OllCTOpllqecll.ie·ocTaTKII •Ie.IOBi>Ka.
Anrporro.ToruqecRan:
BhlcrasKa, .Kar•·h 3a,~y:uanna.a B'I> l\IocKB'B
n ;J;.IJI MocKBIJ, ,:~;o.Iil\.Ha 6LI.ra o6paTJITh csoe IICK.uoqnre.rouoe
BHIUiaHie Ha TOT'D :;uaTepia..I'h. ROTOpiJii OCOOCITHO JIHTepeceH'b
,;r..ra nac1> pycc.liliX'L. J.\IojRerb OliiTn C'b rrepBaro pa3a cepia qepenoB'h
nerpOB'D. AI~repn.KaHciwx·b n.re"'IeH'b, .AscTpa.Iiti.t~eB'b u .J.PYmx'D,
Eaaa.mcn 6IJ unrepecn·l>e cepilt. no.ry'JenuJ.IX.'b H3'h naiJHIX'D
KypraHOH'L H O'f'l> HalllllX'h IIHOpONI,eD1>. IIO 3a TO ord; OhlJUl 6hl
Mente HO.Ie3Hbi. He l'OBOp.ll )'.iKe 0 '[0.:\L'I,, ~ITO BCeCBi>THiiiH ItO.JJreK~iii
co6HpaiOTC.Il ,J,eCJITli.TBTi.:nm u 6o.rl;e aua~mTe.IbU1Drn cpe)~CTBamr,
'IiM'b r·£, IWII mdWICb y lLOm!'re'ra.. Jipii ll8pB01H'h 3HaKOMCTB'£
C'h liUKOIO .moo rpyHilOIO qlal\.TOB1> OOIJI'i.HOBellHO 6pocaiOTCJI
ua •1ro Jin6o oco6o B.b11I,m011~eec.n, }J'B3I10 OT.dWiaiOHI,eecJI:
Tal\.'L 'f0LI!l0 H AHTpOll0.10l'II C'b HepnaL'O }JU3U. OC06eiiHO CIUibHO
3a60TH.'HICL 0 IIO..Iy'leHill qepe!IOB'I, ~ ~a.'I£,1UIX'b II CBOeoopa3HhlX'b
nJie;~reH'.h. A¢pmm, AMepuKa, AscTpa.Iin mrrcpecosa.m HX'n
6o.rl>e, 'l't:~rh o.o.pya•aromi,n llX'b l\d)CTHO<'TI£. H o y,~os.reTBOpHB'D
HepBhlli 111JU.lllB'h :ri060HhlTCTBa 11 OIIIICaB'L> HUII6o.rJ:;e Kypo03HOe,
oB.u npmu.;ur K'b y6t:.K~~eHilO, 'ITO .~.em 6o.rse ceph031i1IX'b ycn·£XOB'h
H)'.iitHO pa:.HmBaT.b IIUYitY He <.:l'O.ll>lLO B'h lllllpb, Cl\.O.lb.I\0 B'D
f.Iy6b. He CTO.lbl\.0 :3a60TIITb<.:JI 0 <.:.Iy'IUiilLO.\l'h OT,~a .. reliHOM'D,
c.n.O.ThKO o cucTe?lraTH'IeC.IiO)I'h usylreuiu 6.1mKalimaro. M :3,I,i>cL
TOiKe He B'b .l\.OC:IIOIIO.IliTII33I'B O.Ka:~a.rca B'hpHblfi ycu'i>X'b ,~a.ilbHtfirnaro
pa:3BHTi.ll, a H'b pa3pa60TK'R ~I'BCTHDIX'h yc.IOBifr JI <.:pe,I,C1~B'h:
c'.b noro 11,i>.IiiO :~re.i:Ii.;I:yuapo~nhle a~rrpouo.wru'JecLl.ie l..:OHrpecchl H
nepece.JIH.IUCn II3n CTpaHhl B'h CTpaHy M.ll 'l'Ol'O, '!'1'0011 B'b K.aJK;~OH
B036y.n:riT:b MtcrnliiH H3C.TB.J;OBaHiJ£ B'h B03}{0iKHO oo.rnme:wb Mac
Стр.2
-3
mTa61>. lloaTOMY ecJIH nama BLICTaBxa J&e.lfa.Ia npanecTH oco6eanyro
IIOJ1b3J ,n;a.llbHi>frrnertry pa3BHTiiO nayKH AHTpOIIO.rroriH, TO ORa
)I.O.rr:JEna gwa rrocTaBHTn ce6t r.rraBni>ihrrero :u;i>.!Iiro pa3pa6oTKY
Toro MaTepiaJia, xoTopLiii .n;aeT'b Poccia, Ti>M'D 6oJii>e, liTO o,n;Ha
PocciJI l\IOJKeT'D .n;ocTaBHTn MaTepia.rr'D, HMi>rom.ilr o6m.eHayqlHilfi
HHTepec·n, )I.JI.a :u;i>Jiaro pH.JI.a BLICTaBOK'b H :u;i>.rrorr cepiH My3eeB'D.
l!CXO)J;Jl H3'.b 9TOll TOql\.H 3pi>HiJI, ltOMHTeT'.b BLICTaBKH H 3aHJIT'.b
6LIJI'b HCKJIIDqHTeJThHO IIO."[yqeHieM'b BCero TOro, lJTO Kaca.rrOCb
Poccin, 3anl\ICTBYJI BHi> npe.n;i>.'IOB'b eJI TO.JlbKO caMoe neo6xo.n:HMoe
)J;JIH IIO.lHOTiii CHCTeMaTHlJeCKarO IIJJaHa BLICTaBKII. MaTepia.rrLI
IIO OTHOilleHiiD Pocciii C06Hpa.rrHCb C'b yqeHLIMH :n;i>.JIJIMH
H OC06eHHO 3a60THJIHCb 0 HX'b HOBII3Hi> H llO.[BOTi>; ,n;aHHLIJI
OTHOCHTe.llbHO He pyCCltHX'b aHTpOllO.llOrnqeCKllX'b BOllpOCOB'.b llpHBJieKa.mCb
Ha BIJCTUBK}' TOJiblW )J;.llH IIOIIyJiapH3aD;iOHHOH H ytie6HOH
:u;·.l>Jiefr.
Y ze IIpemnie H3c.rrt~oBaTe.m: lle.mntqecKHX'L 111exea'b KaR'L
JianpHMilp'b B.1IloMen6 a x'D H ,11;pyrie, o6paTIUH
B~IDiaHie' na. to,
B·.r. PocciH cnapJima.rrHcb oco6LI.a axcne,n;H:u;iH, TpaTH.rriiCb
3HalJHTe.llbHLIJI cpe)J;CTBa Ha pi>menie lJaCTHI:iiX'b BOllpOCOB'b, 3a
rpaHHD;eiD li\.e KOJIJieKTHpOBa.ROCb B'b KOni.aX'b H CHHMKaX'b npeHM'yi:u;eCTBeHHO
TO, lJTO :KacaeTCJI Hau6o.rr'l;e· cyr:u;eCTBeHHLIX'.b BOIIpOCOB'.b
o6n~efi aHTpOllO.liOriii.
AHTpono,;rori.a II3c.rri>)l.yeT·.r., KaK'b H3Bi>cTno, ,n;oKcTopKqecKiJI
n.lleJrieHa n K.liaccH!fnma:u;iro coBpeMeHHLIX'b n.IeMeH'D. C'.h 8TIIX'.b
. ;J;BYX'b TOlJ81t'.b 3pi>HiJI H npOH3BO,ll;H.IOCb KO.I.lleKTHpOBaJii.e llepenOB'.b
H xocT.aKOB'b 06I:u;ecTBOM'b Jiro6nTe.lleii EcTecTB03HaHiJI. Bca
:RpaHiOJJOfllll8CEaJI KO.il.IeKD;iJI ecTeCTBeRHO llOaTOMY ~lOJK.eT'.b 6LITb
no,n;pa3)1;i>JieHa Ha ,ll;OllCTOpKqecK~ H COBpeMeHHyiO, n.rreMeHRyro.
-qTO KacaeTC.a )l:OHCTOpHl!eCKOH KO.li.lleK:n;iH llepenOB'.b H npe,n;MeTOB'.b,
TO ORa l'JiaBHLIM'b o6pa30M'b npe)J;CTaB.llJieT'b MaTepia.rr'b H3'.b RaillHX'b
xypranoB'D n OTHOCHTCJI xo BpeMeHH IX-XII Bi>Ky no P.
X., 3a BecbMa ·Ma.ILIMll ncKJIIDlJeHiJIMII. TaK'b ni>xoTopLie KpLIMcxie
l!epena MOfYT'b 6IiiTb OTHeceHLI K'.b 6o.lli>e paHHeMJ BpeMeHH,
ItaK'D narrpn:r.~i>p'D TaK'.b na3LIBaeMLie MaKpoKelj>a.w, a .n;pyrie,
.ItaKOBLI H3'b KypraHOB'b fipiypa.ThCltllX'b, It'D 6o.lli>e II03)1;Hi>iirneMy;
Ti>M'b He Mente 60JiblliiiHCTBO OTHOCHTC.a HMeHHO R'b CKa3aHHOMY
IIepio)l.y, KOTOIJLlll, )l,'BllCTBHTe.llbHO, HO:atRO Ha3BaTb AOHCTOpHqeCKUM'b
no OTROHieRiiD Pocciu B'b TOM'b CMLIC.llil, liTO TartiJI KypraRHLIJI
II.lieMeHa He OCTaBH.lfll mnero IIOC.llil ce6JI B'b llCTOpiK,
ItpOMil Beiii.eCTB8HHLIX'b ,1I,OKa3aTeJJbCTB'.b CBOero CJI:u;eCTBOBaHiJI
B'.b MOI'llJJaX'b II TO.llbltO H'BK_DTOpLI.a CBOH HMeRa B'.b .Jl':BTOllliCHX'.b.
Bnpo~reM'b na BLICTaBKil, 6Jiaro.n;apH rpalj>y A. C. YBapoBy, naxo,li,HTc.a
l!epeii'b, lWTOpLifi MOjltHO OTReCTll K'I> IIpOTOIICTOpHlJeC.KKM'b
Hapo.n;al\l'.b, nace.lJIBillHl\I'b PocciiO B'b .n;peBHi>ilrnyro anoxy
ItaMel!Haro BilKa, MO.iKeT'b OLITb lt'b COBpeMeRRllltaM'b liClJe3HyBmaro
MaMOHTa n rrocopora. TaKIIX'b IIpOTOHCTOpiilleCKHX'b nJieHeH'b
Terrepb )1.03HaiiO H'liCIW.l.bltO B'b 3ana)l.l!Oll EBpOni> ll IIO)l,'.b
~TllM'L HMeHe.M'b C.il.f3)~yeT'b IJO)I.pa3yMilBaTb TaKi.a llJiertleHa, KOH
JKIIJIH B'h CTOJlb OT)I.a.lleHH)'IO anoxy, lJTO ORa BIIO.llH'B no YC.llOBiHllf'b
CBOeL'O 6hlTa 6:ni.Ia nepBOOLITHOID. 0 TaK.HX'b llJie~JeHaX'.b IICTOpi.a
ne IIO)I.ospilna"m ~a.lli.e ca~mro uxrr, cym.ecTBOBaniJili nx'b yKasa.Ia
eli TO.llbKO COBpel\leHHUJI aHTpOfTOJ
IOri.a.
HaxoJit)l.enie E'h Pocdn: lle.lloB'liKa ~penntH:maro KaJ
neHnaro
rrepio~a JIE.[JI8TCH TO.llbli.O pesy.lloTaTOM'b Cal\ILIX'b llOC.I'B)I.HIIX'b
H3LICKaRifr H ero em,e flOKU MOjKHO CTfUTaTb lJIICTOIO C.lyqafiHOCTiiO,
eCJIH OCTaEHTb E'b CTOpOHil H3C.llil~OBaHiJI, ll}WH3Be)J;eiiHLIH
no 3ana~IIofr rpamm,t Pocciu E'.b nen~epaxr:r, llpHBIIC.llJIHCitaro Kpaa.
HaxO)I.rta STa ;~aeT'b OCHOBaTe.J!>HYIO na,:~;en>Ay, TfTO II B'b .II.PYriiX'b
lrilcTax'J, ualr.II.YT'b CJ
KypraHbl COCTaB.llJIIOT'.b BCe TaiW r.IIaBHilfrmifi 1\IaTepia.ll'.b
liTO ~repeiia pa3JI.HTfHLIX'b llJielleH'.b npe)J.CTaB.liHIOT'.b HilKOTOplla UOCTOJIHRiiUI
OC06eHHOCT.H, no KOIDI'b B03MOJKHO OUll'IHTb WieMJI)I;aJRe
no qeperry; HO TO•lbKO CO BpeMeWI PeT:u;iyca B03p0,11;H.IOCb TO
yqenie o rt.llaccul}lurta:u;ionnLIX'.b npH3Ha.KaX'b ll.lleMeH'.b lle.rront'leCKHX'L,
KOTOpOe li3BilCTRO IIO)I.'.b HMeHeM'.b KpaRiOJIOriH. 300.liOrH,
BllpOllelll'b, em.e npeai.,Ir.e OOpaTHJI.H BRHManie HR TO, lJTO llepena
pa3.ll.HliRLIX'.b JKHBOTHLIX'b npe,n;cTaBJIJIIOT'L llOCTOJlHB.Wl paa.J11111iJI
B'll H3BilCTHLIX'b qepeUHLIX'b yrJiaX'b, Talt'.b ltalt'.b 8TH paa.m'liJI
Olleno pil3KH 11 .lierKo 6pocaroTca B'b uaaa. llpe)l;mecTBeHHH.Kll
peT :u; i y C a ITO aHTpOnOJIOfiH TOJK.e o6pai:u;aJ1H BHHMaHie R8. OT.Jlllqi.a
B'b qepellHLIX'b IIpH3HaKaX'b, HO TO.llb.KO H8. T8.1£i.JI, ROH H8:CTO.llbKO
pil3Kll, liTO CaMH C060ID 6pocaiOTC.a B'b r.Jla3a, H I£0H
MOI'Y'f'b c.rryatHTb OTJI.HtJieM'b UaBHiliiillHX'b rpyllll'.b qe.llOBt'leCKHX'b
rr.lleMeH'D. PeT:u;iycy npHna,n;.J
ie:ii£HT'b Ta 3ac.qra, liTO oUHcaiiie
TllAIJ TaKoro .n;peBnrrro Hace"IeiiiJI, no noKa
)l..liH
Rpanio.llora,· .m.eJJarom.aro BIJJICRHT.b ce6t HapOAOHace.IIeHiJI .n;oHCTOpH'IecKi.a.
I~ypranLI JIB.llJIIDTc.a n B'b ana'lnTe.ThHOfr lJIIC.IIennoCTH
n npl{ necb:tna Y.IJ.OB.[eTEOpliTeJIDHLIX'b apxeo.mrnlfec:rmx'D yclfoBiJIX'h.
Ilo OTHO.llieHiiO 1\HJOI'I1X'b U:3'l> HHX'b B03l\10if\.RO 6WIO XOTJI
npH.OJIH3ll'fe.llbHO OIIpeA'B.lHT.O Ha3BaHffi TOrO llJlellfeHII, KOTOpmry
OIDI npHHU)J;JieJKaJlli, ll BOCllpOII3BeCTH 6oJiile II.llll l\IeHi>e 3aEOHlJ8HnyiD
o6crranoBKY HX'b 6LITa. Ta:rti.a KypraHRLI.a nJie:t~IeHa liiOl')'T'J,
C.llJ.i:KliTb y;~o6HOIO TOlJKOIO RCXO)I.a )J;JI.Jl AaJ
rHqecitHX'.b H3CJiil)I.OBaHifi. 3TH U3CJiil)I.OBUHiJI fJiaBHLIM'b o6pa30M'.b
OCHOBIJBaiOTCH Ha CJiilAYIOIII.elll'b.
ThHiJHUIHX'.b RpaHiOJIOl!epena
OR'b BBe.rr'b He Kalt'.b HCKJIIOlJeHie llpH OllHCaJii.H OCOOeHHO
xapaitTepHLIX'.b ll.lleMeH'b, OT.JlllqaiDI:u;HXC.a pt3KID111 CBOiCTBa.Jm,
HO IIOH.a3a.ll'I~ llpll.liOJKHMOCTb ero K'b pa3JilllleRiiO llJieMeR'.b O,D;HOI:
paCLI H lt'b aRaJ1li3Y II.lleMeHHaro IIpOHCXOJK)IeHiJI CMtmaB.liHX'L
napo,n;OB'b. PeT:u;iyc'h nepBLIK BBe.l'b n qnc.lo:~~oe:oJlPazeiiie,D;DI
r.rraBHtilmaro npH3HaKa, Ra OCHOBaHiH KOero OR'b CTpOH.I'b CBOH
K.laCCHtPHKa:n;iOHHLIJl rpyniiii[, HMeRHO l'O.llOBHaro yKa3aTe.lla, ITO
KOeMy qeperra Ai>.IJITCJI Ra A.llHHHOI'O.llOBLIX'.b H ltOpOT.KOfOJIOBilX'.b.
-qTO fO.[OBI.I 6LIBaiOT'b )J;JIHRRLIJI IIKOpOTI£iJI-9TO 3RaJIH H npellt,D;e,
no Bo nepn:hlx'b ne npH.II.aBa.m 9TOMJ oco6ennaro anaqeJii..a:, a, :oo
BTOpLIX'b, He 3RaJ1ll I£alt'b 9TO BLipa3HTb TOTfHO R8. RaylfROM'b J13LIB.t,
xax'h aTo oxapaxTepH30BaTb nocTOJIHHLIMH npaBHJiaMH. Co BpeHeHH
PeT:u;iyca yKasaHLI npe.n;ilm 9THX'.b no,D;paa)l;ilJieiii.D: H ,D;ano
HX'.b BLipaJK.eaie B'b npo:u;enTROM'b OTHomeHill nan6o.llbmaro lllHpoTHaro
TeMeRHaro ,n;iaMeTpa l'O.IOBLI lt'b RaHOO.llbilleMJ )J;.lllDIROTHOMJ
.llo6no-3aTWOlJHOMJ, H.m nau6oJJDrneMy npo,n;oJJDROMJ. 3a PeTJJ;iycoM'b
Bap'b 11 BpoKa B'.b oco6ennocTH :amoro c,D;il.lla.m ,D;.IJl
B!il.acneni.a Toro HeTo)l.a, C'b no'Moi:u;iiO I£OToparo Harlpeiiie qepeIIOB'b
HOUR CTaTb J,i(06ocpaBHHBaeMLI C'b O)l;tiOit CTOpOHil H
npHBeCTR K'b onpe.II.il.rreairo WieMeHRLIX'b oT.mlfill C'.b .n;pyroH:. KpoHil
fO.llOBHaro yKa3aTe.rrH ycTaHOB.lleHO 6LIJIO HilCKOJibl£0 ,n;pyrHX'b (r.ll8.3HliqHLIH,
3yonoH:, lleJIIOcTaofi, ne6HLIH: H T • .n;.). HaoopilTena.
6i.ua :u;ilJiaJI cepi.a rrpu6opOB'b u caap.a,n;oB'b, noaBO.ll.aBlliHX'b HMilTJJ
HaH60.llile TO~HLIH 113MilpeBiH, HaHMeRile 0JllR601JHLlJI OT'b c;ryqafi.HLIX'b
npUTfHB'b. B'b CaMOM'b Ail.IJ.il, eC.liH pa3.1IHqBIJJI COOTHOmeJii..a:
lJepeiiHiiiX'b pa3MilpOB'b )l.ilHCTBHTe.libHO xapaKTepHCTJiliRLI ,D;.liJl
pa3.l[.HqHJ:iiX'b n.lleMeB'b, To Bee TaKII 8TH paa.mqia Morm . OLITb
BhlHCHeHLI TOJJbltO TOr;-r;a, KOI')I,a Ra6JIID)J;eRi.a CTa.m DpOH3BO)I;HTbCJI
IIO O)l,HOMY 11eTO.li.Y H npH O)I;UllaKOBLIX'b yc.rroBi.ax'b, ,D;il.llaiOI:u;KX'.b
ux'h y.II.o6ocpaBRHBaeMhlMH. Bc.aKOliiY non.arno, liTO ec.m O,ll;HH'b
na6.I£ID,n;aTe.llb, 6y,n;eT'.b lf3Mi>pJITb IUllpHRY llepena y BHCO'IHOfl KOCTII,
. a ,n;pyroff y TeMeHHOll, TO llO.ilylfeHHLie pe3yJihTaTLI He MOryT'b
OLITb cpaBHimaeMhl II oom.aro pe3y.1IbTaTa ne rro;ryqHTCJI OT'.b
llX'b ll3C.lil)I.OBaHiH. liy:iKHO, CJiilAOBaTe.llbHO, 6IiL10 JCTaHOBHTb B'L
Kpanio.lOriii naylJRLIU JI3LIK'b, nO,J;06BLlll TOMy, KOTOpLIH JCT8.HOB.'IeR'b
.l.IHHaeeM'D .II..llJI soo.Ioriu; nyzno 6LI.IO BLipa6oTaTb e.II;llllJIO
naylfHJIO TepMIIHO.lOI'OO, npH KOTOpOll Ka.ilt)I.Llll H3CJiil,D;OBaTe.llb
no.J:'b T'Bl'll'b ll.lll .II.PYriiM'L yKasaTeJJeM'b llepeiia noBHMa.rr'b 6LI o.n;no
u To.ilte. Hy.iKHO obLIO Halr.II.TII Til ncxo.II;HLIH TOlJKU: .II..llJI H3Hilpenili,
KOlll\IOf.lli 6LI 6LITb o6m.eiipiiHHTiiiMH H cqnTUTLCJI 3a llOCTOJIHHLIJI.
Hyamo 6nuo Me.m..a;y ~IHoiKeCTBDll'b B03liiO.iltRLIX'b usMilpeaiH na qeperrt,
n em.e 60.lli>llillM'b KO.l.HqecTBOlll'.b COOTBOllleHifr HX'b, BLI6paTb
T'li, ROll cym.ecTnenrrile u 6o.1ile nocTOJIHRLI. HaKone:u;'L, TpeooBa.'Iocb
)1.03HaTh J RU.ilt,"I;al'O II.Ie:IIeHII B'b OT,iJ,il.lbHOCTH, KaltiJI IDieHHO
U3'b yyll~8CTD8HHLIX'.b K.paHiO.:lOI'liTfeCitliX'b IIpH3HaKOB'b HB.llHIOTCJI
xapaKTepllCTll'lBI:iiMU:: a 3TO npe,:I;CTaB.JJI..IO 3HalJIITeJibHLIJI 3aTpy,1I,HeRiJI
ITO liHOriilll'b IIJ.)HlJIIHalll"b; 113'b KOIIX'b cyr:u;ecTBeHHilfirniJI
c.lli>)l.yrom.ia. Bo nepBI>Ix'.r. y 11mornx'I, n.IeM.eR'b KpaH:ae saTPY.II.HHTe.JihHO
liOJ
Jyqerrie He TO.llbKO 'fHIIII'leCKHX'b TIJieilleBHIJX'b l!epel
UOB'h , HO II B006r:u;e RalWrO ..IU60 llepena; BO BTOpLIX'L Ha 3eMI
IJOM'b mapil ocTa.:IOCb MaJ
IO n.ileMeB'b, KOH oLLm 6LI coBeprneHHo
Стр.3